Sweets By Sarah Bakery

...just wanted to say how amazing the pies you made for Hannibal school are...they looked fabulous tasted delicious...you definitely know how to bake...I'll definitely be a repeat customer ???

Great smoothies and cookies! Mint chocolate chip was my fave cookie!

Ordered cupcakes for my husband’s birthday and they were amazing!!! We camp in Fair Haven every year and this is going to be a new tradition.

Let's start with the positives.It is a nice little shop with nice people. Everything presents well. I purchased a chocolate chip cookie, a sandwich cookie, a peach pie bar, a brownie and a cinnamon roll. Total cost $20.59.I have had a worse chocolate chip cookie I just can't remember when. It had no flavor and wasn't baked enough. The sandwich cookie was the same, bland and not baked long enough. The filling tasted like sweetened shortening. The peach pie bar was also disappointing, again very bland. The bottom crust was good and the sliced peach added some much needed flavor. The brownie was a better option. Very fudgy and tasty! The cinnamon roll, although good, did not live up to the rave reviews I'm seeing here. It would have been better without the icing. The icing again was flavorless and there was far too much of it. In all honesty you can get better cookies and frosting from the Wal-Mart bakery. The great reviews I'm seeing here certainly didn't reflect what I tried today.

Friendly service and delicious sweets. We found a new favorite in town!