Rosalie's Pizza - Town Hill

After a minute to figure out self seating and ordering, we enjoyed amazing pizza! Can’t go wrong with this pizza and the vibe was very cool!!

Pizza and music are both great! Reasonable amount of seating. Definitely go if you are craving New York style pizza. You won't be disappointed.

This is the best last time I had it was 2008 and I made it a point to visit when I vacationed up this way again.

Food: I was truly disappointed by the food. The food SMELLS good from outside the restaurant, but that’s about it! The garlic bread wasn’t garlic bread. Putting butter and a few chopped up pieces of garlic on a white bun isn’t garlic bread. What was much worse was the undercooked, wet calzone. You can tell they rush their cooking because of the sheer volume of customers. The first several bites of the calzone was just dough! The filling inside was flavorless. They try to show off as a true Italian restaurant with their Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin photos, and their deep red and green decor, but I promise you as an Italian American myself that what they make is NOT the flavorful, rich Italian food you want it to be. They make Nonna Rosalie want to roll in her grave with the way they cook their sub-par food! Service: Cashier didn’t greet me when I walked up to order even though she clearly saw me approaching and when I walked up, she immediately put her head down and ignored me. Finally, once she greeted me, I gave my order, but at that point the service was already feeling sub-par and as if all the tourists were the reason why the staff wasn’t friendly. Atmosphere: Italian pictures and decor make it feel authentic.

We really liked the pizza and cheese bread. The lady upstairs helped us find a table. She was very sweet. However I have never heard of an eating place that takes 45 min to receive your food and doesn't give one free refills on soda. We had finished our drinks by the time our pizza came! Really disappointed with that policy!