Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Dee likes about Coral Bay Cafe:
What a great experience every time! Food is so good! We’ve had the Shrimp Oreganata, Fettuccine Lobster and Shrimp, and a few of the pasta dishes. Mussels are delicious, especially in the red sauce Definitely recommend the Ricotta/Pistachio cake! View all feedback.
What Natalie Krüger doesn't like about Coral Bay Cafe:
Food and drinks were great but the service was HORRIBLE. Made a reservation for 7 got there at 7 but we waited for a half an hour before being seated. They brought the wrong food out twice. They also did this to two other tables next to us. The entrees took forever to come out… we were in the restaurant for over two hours and we didn’t even get dessert. The staff was nice just disorganized. I think they were trying t... View all feedback.
The first time in this restaurant for my 36th year. my man and I could not believe the quality of the food. a very friendly staff even sung us. everything was just delicious. I am very fussy with eating, but baked muddles amazing. shrimp oreganata is perfect and utter for my man. Drink and gloomy! so happy we found a great place to eat! thanks for everything!
read moreFood service very good. simple parking nice place friendly. will return definitiw.
My first trip to staten island and glad we found this gem. great eating, personal and atmosphere.
Me and the most beautiful woman I have ever met..had are first date here...and it is happily ever after for us...this is truly are favorite place...
Grate place by the beach ! Authentic food Italian food , awesome interior! Bellissimo