Reviews
What User doesn't like about Johnny’s New York Style Pizza:
I ordered a 'supreme' pizza, medium. The green peppers were so tiny, I couldn't taste them. The mushrooms were almost not present, and it had too much sausage and pepperoni!! I didn't taste or see cheese or tomato sauce!? It was very bad. The 'Arnold Palmer' tea I tasted like hot water or worse!! It was very disgusting and they had the nerve to charge $23.00 for this garbage! I'm a native New Yorker, so I know how to... View all feedback. What User likes about Johnny’s New York Style Pizza:
After moving to the Atlanta area of New York in 2018, we struggled to find a great Italian restaurant until we discovered Johnnys. While I do miss Ray's famous pizza in the West Village, Johnny's is a close second. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Three words I would use to describe this place are amazing, professional, quality, tasty, cheesy, yummy, mouth water, from this world.
We picked up some calzones that I had the mushrooms and pfefferoni and my friend had the italian. both very good. they have a quite wide menu and a very.
I always order a slice or pizza with each topping. the pizza is pretty good. ordered the auberginen parm sandwich once, which I do not recommend.
After moving to the Atlanta area of New York in 2018, we struggled to find a great Italian restaurant until we discovered Johnnys. While I do miss Ray's famous...
read moreI ordered a 'supreme' pizza, medium. The green peppers were so tiny, I couldn't taste them. The mushrooms were almost not present, and it had too much sausage a...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreNestled within a vibrant community, local pizzerias offer a mix of experiences that can range from culinary bliss to utter disappointment. While some guests rave about exceptional pizza, like the Hawaiian with garlic butter, and praise the attentive staff, others recount unfortunate encounters—burnt pies delivered cold or lacking essential toppings. Concerns about cleanliness and food handling have also surfaced, dampening appetites. Despite these inconsistencies, some patrons sing the praises of generous portions and a charming atmosphere, making it clear that while all may not be perfect, there is still hope for delightful dining experiences.