Martha's Leelanau Table - Suttons Bay

Marthas has not disappointed! our “Date Night” event was the best we had from Martha’s leelanau table. we ordered a lake steak with a perfectly made steak, medium rare together with a Bourbon-Maple glaze (just more like a big filet) and 2 lake perch with a crispy teig (dinking maybe panko) along with a zucchini carrot medley crushed redskin kartoffeln and sea scallops so perfectly boiled huge! there were no spots of grit in them; and they were accompanied by a wonderful brazed brittle sprout with speck and kartoffeln. included was a nice piece of crispy baguette for two. always included with date night is a carefully selected bottle wein (they say whether they prefer a red or white;) tonight was an Italian white that perfectly paired with our meal. this cold winter night was surely more inviting!

They need a proof of jab to eat here. No, thanks. we will not support a business that requires this. the obedient always thinks of himself as virtuous and not cowardly

Wonderful atmosphere, food and service was awesome! Definitely a must visit stop in Sutton’s Bay!

Ate here on October 7th. Outside area was absolutely charming with a cello and piano player so nice.

I was hoping to take my family here tonight, as I've dined at Martha's before. I made multiple calls (13 to be exact) to try and make a reservation since their website says they take reservations starting at 2pm and/or you can contact them via an email link. They never answered, and the email link provided doesn't work because their mailbox was full. Not a great way to run a business. When they finally answered the phone 2 days later, they were lamely apologetic. I'm not sure I would go back, as there are lots of other places in town. I would encourage you to update your website to reflect the accuracy of the hours that you say you will start taking reservations...or just don't take reservations at all.. Super frustrating.