Reviews - Sutter Cut Pizzeria

Pizza, Italian, Pizzeria

Reviews summary

Overall Total Score
4.2 out of 5
Impressive | 558 reviews

Was Margot Simonis at Sutter Cut Pizzeria a mag?

We came for lunch and had an amazing experience! The salad bar, Hawaiian calzone, and Sutter Cut pizza were all delicious. The staff were very warm and welcoming. I highly recommend this spot and can’t wait to come back! View all feedback.

What Leah Costan dislikes about Sutter Cut Pizzeria:

The pizza is tasty, but it's quite cheesy and challenging to eat. The thin crust doesn't support the toppings well, causing them to slide off when you try to pick it up—I'd recommend using a fork. The customer service is good, and they have arcade games available. Overall, I’d give it a 6/10. I probably wouldn’t order pizza again, but I’m open to trying a calzone. View all feedback.

Reviews from various users

Sirved

Last update : 13.06.2025

4.4 ★ from 8 reviews
amy-parisian
13.06.2025

Glad to find this Lil hidden spot. Awesome salad bar...fully stocked unlike most pizza restaurants. Calzone was bombastical !!! Delicious !! Fast Excellent service. Be back soon.

froob-store96
13.06.2025

Got me Large Garden Veggie Pizza and added Pepperoni Linguica to it. It was so good I almost ate the whole pie by myself in one sitting...lol The flavors from the artichokes, tomatoes, olives, and all the other veggies with the pepperoni linguicamade it such a delicious tasting pizza. Definitely recommend as a great pizza place to either eat in or take home and will forsure go there again.

valentina-romanchenk-1
13.06.2025

I'm in here having my lunch special all of a sudden I hear commotion back in the kitchen apparently one or both of the male employees were harassing the female. I hear throwing of dishes back and forth arguing in Hispanic or whatever other languagethey speak I think they're Hispanic it's calm down now but it boy it was escalating and it looked like the female is trying tosmack one of the other ones I don't know it was have a strange experience and you know being in here eating some good pizza andthen all of a sudden hear all this commotion and it interrupts your good time eating food

gabe-barton
13.06.2025

GREAT PIZZA NEVER HAD ANYHTING CLOSE TO THIS, STAFF IS VERY FRIENDLY AND PIZZA IS UNMATCHED!!! IF YOU HAVE NEVER TRIED THIS PIZZA BEFORE ITS A MUST. HIGHLY RECCOMEND THIS PIZZA IF YOU ARE EVER IN THE AREA!!! THIS PIZZA IS IMMACULANT. IT IS A GREATPIZZA FOR YOU AND ALL YOUR FAMILY. THEY EVEN HAVE A GIANT SALAD BAR AND A BIG SELECTION OF ARCADE GAMES. THIS RESTURANT IS GOINGTO BE MAINSTREAM SOON SO ITS BETTER TO BE APART OF IT SOONER THAN LATER!!!!!!!!!!!

leah-costan
23.12.2023

Fantastic pizza! I really appreciate how it’s located away from all the urban hustle and bustle—perfect for a pleasant drive in the countryside. There's an arcade for the kids, and they offer booth seating as well. They also have great lunch specials. I'm surprised this place isn't more popular!

Google

Last update : 22.11.2023

4.4 ★ from 129 reviews
leandro-addarich-1
22.11.2023

I prefer my calzone to be crispy, and while mine wasn't, I still enjoyed it. It was good overall!

jd-yup-pilot7911
22.11.2023

Service: Takeout Food: 4/5 Service: 5/5 Atmosphere: 3/5

charon-garing
22.11.2023

If John Taffer had been observing, this place would have undoubtedly failed their stress test. After our game, most of our team decided to visit, and here’s how it went. The food was enjoyable — my husband and son particularly loved the pizza. The salad bar was also impressive, allowing for a delicious salad. Unfortunately, the wings didn’t have that crispy texture I was hoping for. Even after I tried to revive them in my air fryer at home, they never reached that desired crunch. However, they did have great flavor. If you prefer wings that aren't crispy, my son thinks they’re fantastic! The venue also features a small arcade and pool area, which adds to the fun. On a kid-friendly note, they have a change machine for the games, so there's no need to hassle the front cashier for quarters.

little-relics
22.11.2023

Arrived after a soccer game and the food was clearly homemade and delicious. Crust bread were amazing and the blt was on point. Next time we are in town, we will be back. Highly recommend and love that it is family owned operated and beer is real cold! Vegetarian options: fresh produce, crispy lettuce on the blt Parking: a lot of parking in front Kid-friendliness: video games Service: Dine in

karen-peck
22.11.2023

We found out they have only been open for 2 weeks. Took over from old owners, but that's my guess. The beer from tap is super cold. And the pizza, WOW. We got the Veggie. The crust was thin and well done, sooooo good! Alot of cheese and small chopped veggies. Just how I like it. Personally I would of ordered light cheese. But for cheese lovers, yah. Vegetarian options: Don't know the options. But the Veggie was DELICIOUS. Service: Dine in

Menu

Last update : 26.10.2022

4.2 ★ from 10 reviews
graham-jesus
26.10.2022

I'm in here having my lunch special all of a sudden I hear commotion back in the kitchen apparently one or both of the male employees were harassing the female. I hear throwing of dishes back and forth arguing in Hispanic or whatever other language they speak I think they're Hispanic it's calm down now but it boy it was escalating and it looked like the female is trying to smack one of the other ones I don't know it was have a strange experience and you know being in here eating some good pizza and then all of a sudden hear all this commotion and it interrupts your good time eating food

felicity-aufderhar
26.10.2022

Sutter Cut Pizzeria offers truly exceptional pizza unlike anything I've ever tasted. The staff is warm and welcoming, making the experience even better. If you haven’t visited yet, it’s definitely worth a try! I highly recommend it to anyone nearby—you won’t regret it. The pizza is outstanding and ideal for both individuals and families. Plus, they feature a large salad bar and a great variety of arcade games. This place is quickly gaining popularity, so be sure to visit before it becomes a big name!

almira10
26.10.2022

I ordered the Large Garden Veggie Pizza with added Pepperoni Linguica, and it was so tasty I almost ate the whole thing myself in one go! The mix of artichokes, tomatoes, olives, and other vegetables combined with the pepperoni linguica created an amazing flavor. I highly recommend Sutter Cut Pizzeria for a fantastic pizza, whether you’re dining in or taking it to go. I’ll definitely be coming back!

amy-parisian
26.10.2022

We have tried this pizza place several times and the pizza is not to our liking. The bottom is always too burned for us.

simonis-margot
26.10.2022

We came for lunch and had an amazing experience! The salad bar, Hawaiian calzone, and Sutter Cut pizza were all delicious. The staff were very warm and welcoming. I highly recommend this spot and can’t wait to come back!

Facebook
4.1 ★ from 103 reviews
Yelp
4.1 ★ from 17 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.3 ★ from 227 reviews
Restaurantji
4.6 ★ from 64 reviews

FAQ

These Photos from Sutter Cut Pizzeria from Sutter were provided by the community of Menu added. They show the dining room at Sutter Cut Pizzeria, the interior, the location and of course great Photos of the tasty dishes from Sutter Cut Pizzeria.

Good Rated Restaurants near Sutter