Seafood Barn - Supply
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Seafood Barn in Supply. At the moment, there are 22 dishes and drinks on the menu.
**Dining at the Seafood Barn: A Mixed Bag Experience** Nestled along the Carolina coast, the Seafood Barn evokes nostalgia for many, yet recent visits reveal a spectrum of experiences. While some diners praise the fresh seafood and generous portions, others lament greasy dishes and inadequate service. Although the decor and family-friendly atmosphere charm guests, complaints about overpriced meals, inconsistency in seasoning, and occasional rudeness among staff persist. Patrons appreciate the health-conscious practices and homemade sauces but advise focusing on seafood to ensure satisfaction. Overall, it stands as a beloved yet polarizing destination, beckoning return visits for some while driving others to seek alternatives nearby.
Images
Feedback
Was User at Seafood Barn a mag?
first most people only check bad things. That's quite different! I come from someone who has traveled the world; My father has spoken very much about the seafood barn for years! I finally got it here and made it! I know what this is about now! I ordered 2 appetizers and shared a large seafood cellar! the seafoods are fresh in contrast to other seafood from here to myrtle! with what is said, I ate in a seafood restaur... View all feedback.
What User dislikes about Seafood Barn:
I don't know how you did it. that was terrible from beginning to end. clam chowder was not discarded hot came from a dose. garnelen burger was thrown popcorn garnelen on a bungalow, I could not believe my eyes no burger at all. clam strips were cold. they have screwed a chicken caesar salad and put on it. the disappointment is a massive understatement. I was hoping for a decent eating my expectations were enormous th... View all feedback.
It is with great dismay that I cannot give five stars. Although our food was so delicious I cannot go below four stars. The reason for being less than five was first the service was so slow that our food arrived one hour and fifteen minutes into the meal. Yes the hush puppies were great but one can only endure so much of them. Second, when the kitchen runs out they are out for a reason so please don't hold up your guests by making them wait an hour for their apps
Not sure where all the hate comes from for this place but, they've been in biz since the 70's so they have to be doing something right. What they are doing right is reasonably priced seafood, mostly fried, served by friendly people. Check, check and check. Don't be scared. Come eat some decent seafood at a decent price.
So we were early birds tonight. We couldn't have been anymore pleased with the service or food. And this is two days after Hurricane Matthew. It's been a good while since we've had the seafood portions that we got tonight. I had 14 grilled jumbo shrimp with a perfectly baked sweet potato. My husband had at least a dozen coconut shrimp. If they weren't hand breaded I would LOVE to know the supplier. They were divine and covered with coconut. We didn't even need the dip. My husband said it was like having shrimp and dessert at the same time. Another entree was the burger. It was huge! Fresh lettuce and tomato covers a big ole patty on top of a fluffy kaiser roll. Happy, happy, happy was the one who didn't want seafood. They brought out a basket full on mini-hush puppies with honey butter. I'm not sure if they were laced with a highly addictive drug or not because we couldn't quit eating them. They were seriously good! We were too full for dessert but I'm sure it would have been equally delectable. So glad for the great reviews. We were very happy with the service and food.
I had dinner here with a friend, and we ordered the same dish. Unfortunately, they only brought one meal at first, and by the time I finished mine, they finally brought my friend's order. We had ordered Pork Chops, Chicken Breast, and Shrimp, but the only highlight was the Shrimp. My friend ordered a Bud Light, and when it arrived, the server mentioned it was the last one available. I ordered a Michelob Ultra, and he informed me that they only had one left of that as well. Overall, I wasn't impressed with this place. While the server was friendly, it was clear that the restaurant is not well-managed.
The food was excellent and the staff was fantastic. We had a group of 20 on Friday night and were seated within just 15 minutes. The hush puppies were delicious, and the crab dip was fantastic. The stuffed flounder was exquisite. I highly recommend this restaurant—I'm completely satisfied!
Full Menu
Appetizers
"Redneck" Ogrelle$8.1Seafood Platters
Shrimp & Grits Sampler$8.1Local Favorites
Chop And Jumbo Shrimp$18.6Senior Specials
Senior Spaghetti And Side$10.4
Senior Seafood (Choice)$13.9Lunch/Dinner (Antipasti, Starters & Salads)
Stuffed Onion$9.3
More information
QR-code link to the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.9 / 5 (1038 reviews)Ice Cream Desserts YogurtFantasy Isle Ice Cream
Holden Beach Road SW 3354, 28462 Supply, US
"The flavor of "Holden Beach Sand" is absolutely delicious."
★ 4.6 / 5 (1972 reviews)#16 Seafood in Supply Grill AmericanSonja's Grill
Coastal Dr SW 15, 28462 Supply, US
"Awesome! Had the Carolina burger with fries and it was delicious"
★ 4.5 / 5 (1511 reviews)Delis Sandwiches Delivery ServicesArchibald's Deli Rotisserie
Holden Beach Rd SW 2991, 28462 Supply, US
"Our go-to place for friendly service, great lunches!"