Bagelicious - Suffern

Been buying their bagels for decades. Sooo good that our relatives who moved to Wisconsin always bring some them back home when they come to visit. We are so sp... read more Been buying their bagels for decades. Sooo good that our relatives who moved to Wisconsin always bring some them back home when they come to visit. We are so spoiled by these that others pale by comparison. Nice bakery cafe food are a plus also.

Bagel Boys has been in Suffern for over 30 years. The community has watched and supported them as they grew from a two man bagel stop to a full service bagel an... read more Bagel Boys has been in Suffern for over 30 years. The community has watched and supported them as they grew from a two man bagel stop to a full service bagel and deli cafe. I recently made a credit card purchase and noted that the actual transaction was more than the bill. It turns out that Bagel Boys (remember, who the community has supported through the years) imposes a 3.99% SURCHARGE on ALL credit card transactions. No other businesses in this community impose a surcharge on credit card transactions. In fact, I've never paid a surcharge on my bills ever! If you count gas stations that's a whole other story! Also, a word of advice to BB's customers. When the cashier asks if you want your receipt, do not hesitate to take it. Inspect it and make sure they're not charging you more than you should. Buyer beware!

We are staying in a hotel down the road, so we brought bagels and coffee back to our room. Bagel Boys was very busy, but the line moved quickly. They offer bage... read more We are staying in a hotel down the road, so we brought bagels and coffee back to our room. Bagel Boys was very busy, but the line moved quickly. They offer bagels, baked goods (muffins, Danish and such) and also have a full deli and Italian cookie and desserts counter. Their bagels are a good 5-6” in diameter!They offer many cream cheese varieties, as well as breakfast sandwiches. We stuck to bagels and cream cheese. We also got 4 coffees, which they put the cream and sugar in for you. The gal that took our order was very nice. Despite the place being packed, everyone working seemed to be in a good mood (not frazzled by the fast work). You pay at a counter by the door. The gal there was very friendly! This is the Disney World of Bagels!! Very efficient. Moved people through quickly. Got them everything they wanted. With a smile. We will be back for their delicious bagels again!!

The bagels here are really good but, they offer many more food options. I had a grilled chicken sandwich and my son had an egg sandwich . Both were very good. E... read more The bagels here are really good but, they offer many more food options. I had a grilled chicken sandwich and my son had an egg sandwich . Both were very good. Everything looks so yummy and fresh. I try to come during the week because weekends can get very busy. They do have tables inside if you want to eat here.

My husband and I were on a road trip and were in NJ to visit family. We lived there for about 16 years and I really missed the bagels in the NYC metro area. The... read more My husband and I were on a road trip and were in NJ to visit family. We lived there for about 16 years and I really missed the bagels in the NYC metro area. The bagel shop wasn't far from our hotel and on our way out of town. I ordered an everything bagel with plain cream cheese and my husband got an onion bagel with scallion cream cheese, along with coffee and bottled orange juice. The bagels were large and very good. We looked at the muffins too and they were large also. My husband said the coffee was good.