Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Tyler Douglas likes about The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza:
As a pizza lover, bartender at Deninos, and a Staten Island Local, Goodfellas keeps up with the pack and is a hidden gem like most restaurants in the forgotten borough. Pizza is delicious!! View all feedback.
What evelyn santiago doesn't like about The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza:
I went for my son’s birthday dinner 3 of us. Sat July 13. The food was ok. I was so excited about going tell my son. The owner comes by. We tell him we are happy with our meal. We valet the car. We leave drive off. I get out the car. The key Lights goes on. The kid that was doing valet forgot to give my husband the car. My husband call the restaurant tells them I want to speak to the owner. He doesn’t get on the phon... View all feedback.
To our surprise, the pizza arrived quickly, and it was piping hot and absolutely amazing. We ordered a large pie topped with fresh mozzarella and sausage. The red sauce was light and perfectly balanced—not too sweet at all—and the crust was wonderfully crispy. I can confidently say that the pizza at Goodfella's in Staten Island definitely lives up to the hype surrounding New York pizza. We can't wait to return on our next trip north!
I really enjoyed the pizza! The cucumber cooler was just right for either a warm or cool day and paired perfectly with our pizza. The crust was spot on—crisp and delicious.
The food here was fantastic, especially the pizza! The service was exceptional, with managers Scott and our waiter Angelina being incredibly friendly and welcoming. I would definitely come back!
This was our first time at this location! Our Seever was George and he was FANTASTIC- personable and just made the experience even better! The food was absolutely delicious and freshly made! We will be back again and again!
One of the best restaurants with delicious food and the best valet company (Premier Valet). Dana’s espresso martinis are top tier
More information
QR-code link to the menu
