Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Salvatore Zito likes about Brother's Pizzeria:
I live on the other side of the island and decided to try this place after hearing great things about their pizza. I have to say, this restaurant has the best square pizza on the island. Their grandma square pizza had a nice crunch to the crust and just the right amount of tomato sauce and cheese. It was delicious. View all feedback.
What kim hines doesn't like about Brother's Pizzeria:
I went to the restaurant to buy two slices of food. I was standing at the counter, but no one approached me to ask if I needed help, even though they were assisting everyone who came in after me. View all feedback.
I went to the restaurant to buy two slices of food. I was standing at the counter, but no one approached me to ask if I needed help, even though they were assisting everyone who came in after me.
The pizza at this restaurant has been delicious for many years and continues to impress. I highly recommend it.
In my opinion, this is the best pizza on Staten Island if you don't prefer thin crust. Your order is always ready in 15 minutes, and the guys behind the counter are always friendly. The pizza is large, the cheese is high quality, and the sauce is delicious.
A staple of the Island. Only reason they don't have 5 stars is they don't deliver
Love their square pie. All dishes have generous portions. Great red sauce and vodka sauce
Full Menu
Pizza
Entrées
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
