Serafina's Pizza - St. Johns

We were recommended to come to Serafinas for authentic NY pizza. There was no disappointment here! The pizza was perfect, thin fold in half pizza, delicious all the way to the crust.

This place is amazing. We had a great experience. The owner is so sweet and kind. Pizza was delicious, this was the best pizza I ever had in America. We’ll definitely come back again.

This is how a pizza joint should be run!I have NEVER left a review anywhere before. This place deserves it. Food is consistently great. Atmosphere is the family environment you would want from a local restaurant. It’s lively, fresh, full of love for their craft. We order there on the regular have yet to be disappointed.Only one mistake made when brought to their attention, the amount of accountability was mind blowing. Their pride in service product quality is unmatched. Prove me wrong. My suggestions are if it’s a busy night call in ahead or be ready to wait enjoy the chaos. Pizza is great the next day. Order more than you think you’ll eat. Pay cash get to know the staff, it’s worth it.Once again. CALL AHEAD, PAY CASH, ORDER MORE.

Delicious pizza and super friendly staff! The garlic knots were really good too!

Very cozy family owned place. The pizza and desert are very good.I was a little confused when ordering the margarita pizza and ended up ordering the wrong one, but the owner was very professional and caring when dealing with my frustration.Next time, I want to eat there instead of taking out. Everything will taste even better.