Pizza Time - St. Augustine

Cash only! Make sure you have cash before you lineup and order. We were taking our order and got surprised that they only accept cash and we are in 2022 But the good thing that they gave us the food and said come back later to pay. Pizzas were really good, try their special.

The Pizza really is that good, staff is very friendly, especially Ms. Donna who was very attentive considering it is a grab and go. Cons, it's cash only and very expensive, up to $9.95 a slice... that would be equivalent to $80 for a full pizza pie... 11 people was over $260 and that was modest, about two slices per person sharing four sodas and four beers

Second best pizza in the nation? I’d say more like second best pizza on the block. The pizza wasn’t bad but that was just it, not bad. At $7 a slice I expected incredible pizza but was ultimately disappointed. I was just glad we had enough cash to pay since there’s no signs outside letting you know it’s cash only.

The pizzas here are delicious, and the wait in line is definitely worth it. They sell their pizzas by the slice, with prices ranging from $4.50 to $9.50, depending on the type. I’m not certain if there are any pizzas priced higher than that. The slices are generously sized, making them a great option for a meal. One important thing to note: they only accept cash. Overall, this is a fantastic pizza spot that I highly recommend!

This pizza place is fantastic! My family and I spent three days in St. Augustine and were eager to try it. In the evenings, there was a huge line stretching down the street just to place an order. We decided to go at 2:00 PM, and that turned out to be a great choice. There was a bit of a wait, but it was worth every second! We tried the chicken parmesan pizza, white pizza, and buffalo mozzarella margherita pizza. I highly recommend giving this place a try! The staff was also wonderful!