Casey's - Sioux Falls

I regularly use the Upside app to buy gas and take advantage of discounts at Casey's. Unfortunately, since Casey's doesn’t connect with my credit card’s auto-ch... read more I regularly use the Upside app to buy gas and take advantage of discounts at Casey's. Unfortunately, since Casey's doesn’t connect with my credit card’s auto-check feature, I need to have my transactions verified by Upside. Despite having a receipt showing that I purchased $80 worth of gas, this particular Casey's location was unhelpful and refused to process my claim, even though it was clearly their receipt. Furthermore, even if this issue gets resolved, I've found better discounts at the BP station nearby. On top of that, the pumps felt outdated, and I didn’t always feel safe at this location.

I ordered a breakfast pizza deal that came with cheese sticks and 8 wings. Unfortunately, the pizza was quite disappointing; there were holes throughout the dou... read more I ordered a breakfast pizza deal that came with cheese sticks and 8 wings. Unfortunately, the pizza was quite disappointing; there were holes throughout the dough, the cheese mix was burnt, and I didn’t receive any marinara sauce. For the wings, I specifically requested boneless but received traditional wings with bones instead. To make things worse, when I threw away the wings box, I noticed a timestamp on the bottom indicating they had been prepared at 4 o'clock. This clearly shows that my wings were simply taken from a pre-heated batch instead of being freshly made. This level of carelessness is completely unacceptable. I can safely say I won’t be ordering from here again; you've lost a loyal customer after many years.

The price led me to believe their pizza would be worth trying, but unfortunately, that wasn't the case. It felt like they didn’t prioritize the quality of what... read more The price led me to believe their pizza would be worth trying, but unfortunately, that wasn't the case. It felt like they didn’t prioritize the quality of what they served; I ended up with a lackluster cheese pizza.

This was supposed to be a taco pizza, but it was disappointing. Generally, we love Casey's pizza, but this was the worst one we've ever had. To make matters wor... read more This was supposed to be a taco pizza, but it was disappointing. Generally, we love Casey's pizza, but this was the worst one we've ever had. To make matters worse, it left us feeling unwell the next day. We were just passing through Sioux Falls, and I would suggest avoiding ordering from the Casey's on Kiwanis Ave.

Took it by a chance that they got better at making pizza but no. You can tell they they do not give two craps about what they serve. and this was a small cheese... read more Took it by a chance that they got better at making pizza but no. You can tell they they do not give two craps about what they serve. and this was a small cheese pizza