Subway - Sidney

#23 - Fast Food - Sidney, Sandwiches, American

Subway

Subway
3.5 / 5 (2173 reviews)

Description

This local Subway has garnered a reputation for inconsistency, marrying moments of excellent service with frustratingly long wait times and order inaccuracies. While some patrons praise the attentive and friendly staff who craft satisfying sandwiches, others express disappointment over poorly prepared salads and overwhelming delays, particularly during lunch hours. Complaints about unmotivated workers and insufficient staffing persist, discouraging some customers from returning. However, for those who strike a positive note, the caring attitude of the team not only enhances the meal experience but also fosters a welcoming atmosphere that keeps them coming back.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Rylee

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 2173 reviews

I would not recommend visiting this particular Subway location. They consistently struggle to accurately fulfill orders and their staff may argue with customers when mistakes are made. It would be better to visit the locations in Wapakoneta or the ones inside Walmart instead.

I visit subway every so often and this location has been so understanding and caring and awesome! I generally ask for a ridiculously unhealthy amount of pickles on my subs and today i was not disappointed! Delicious sub, even paid for Pro status to get the bonus meat. Thank you for the amazing meal tonight.

fairhaven-farm
28.02.2024

My experience at Subway on 10/29/23 for lunch was disappointing. We waited in line for about 20 minutes before ordering 2 sandwiches. We tried to present a coupon before ordering but were told to hold onto it and present it at the cash register later. After our sandwiches were made, we tried to use the coupon but were told that the system was having issues and we would have to pay full price, which was $21 instead of $12 with the coupon. Despite our protests, the off-duty manager insisted on charging us full price, leading us to refuse to pay. Instead of finding a solution, the manager decided to throw away the sandwiches, causing unnecessary waste. This was not the fault of the employees working that day, but rather poor decision-making by the manager. In the future, we will be going to the Subway in Walmart instead. It was a missed opportunity for good customer service.

rylee-vestal
28.02.2024

This restaurant used to be great when I worked there and had a fun atmosphere. Unfortunately, it has gone downhill. It now takes 20-30 minutes to get a sub, only for it to be completely wrong. I don't understand why it takes so long and comes out so incorrectly. It is a terrible experience now.

amby-morrison-2
28.02.2024

The staff is always friendly and smiling. Fast service at the drive-thru for a quick and efficient experience.

Menu

FAQ

You can watch major sporting events on a screen / TV right in the joint.

The restaurant accepts the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.