Murphy’s Craft Kitchen - Sidney

American, Bar-lounge, Beer
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Murphy’s Craft Kitchen

Murphy’s Craft Kitchen
4.4 / 5 (58 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 46 meals and beverages can be found here on the menu of Murphy’s Craft Kitchen from Sidney.

Nestled in downtown Sidney, this restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring dishes like chicken chopped salad and fish and chips, praised for their taste and prompt delivery. However, service inconsistencies mar the overall experience, with reports of slow acknowledgment from staff and wobbly tables detracting from the atmosphere. While some patrons appreciated the extensive tap beer selection and cozy ambiance, others found the dining room too dark and noise levels excessive. Safety concerns about pandemic protocols were also raised. Despite its potential, the restaurant needs to address service issues to elevate the dining experience further.

Last update: 02.03.2026 from: Melany

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 58 reviews

Was Jillian Gleichner at Murphy’s Craft Kitchen a mag?
The atmosphere was great and the food was amazing it was delivered very quickly to our table which was surprising but appreciated. I was expecting a longer wait time due to the amount of people in the restaurant, but our meal was delivered promptly and was delicious. Our server was super nice, but was unfortunately a little busy. Overall great service though. Will come again. View all feedback.

What Melany Donnelly dislikes about Murphy’s Craft Kitchen:
We made reservations and arrived a few minutes early. A couple walked in before us without masks mandated by Ohio’s COVID-19 requirements and the greeter had no issues. We were then seated literally 4’ always from another party (also not wearing masks . We shifted to another table and the server then arrived (also without a mask . We asked for a few minutes to decide. During that time they continued to seat more and... View all feedback.

ndrozdova
06.12.2022

I sat at the bar and had a wonderful experience. The service was excellent, and the nachos were delicious!

felipa87
06.12.2022

Wanted fish and chips. They were out of french fries.

felipa87
06.12.2022

Food was great, my only complaints is that the service was not great. We didn’t have silverware until we asked for it. We constantly asked for refills of water and when we asked one of the food runners she didn’t even know how to get a new bottle. Seems odd there isn’t some slight cross training there. Overall it was good, but the service could’ve been better. They weren’t that busy when we came.

melany37
06.12.2022

We made reservations and arrived a few minutes early. A couple walked in before us without masks mandated by Ohio’s COVID-19 requirements and the greeter had no issues. We were then seated literally 4’ always from another party (also not wearing masks . We shifted to another table and the server then arrived (also without a mask . We asked for a few minutes to decide. During that time they continued to seat more and more people around us (closer than 6’ . We looked around and noticed none of the other servers or bartenders were wearing masks. We were concerned for our safety in the environment and left without ordering

melany37
06.12.2022

Great time and will definitely go back !

Menu

  • Handcrafted Starters

    Mini Hot Dog Sliders
    Mini Hot Dog Sliders
    $11.9
  • Mac + Cheese

    Southern Bbq Mac
    Southern Bbq Mac
    $12.8
  • Burger

    Smoked Gouda Bbq Bacon Burger
    Smoked Gouda Bbq Bacon Burger
    $14.3
    Classic American Cheeseburger*
    Classic American Cheeseburger*
    $13.3
  • Kids

    Kids Fry
    Kids Fry
    $2.0
  • Crisp Salads

    Hot Bacon Spinach Salad
    Hot Bacon Spinach Salad
    $11.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.