Reviews
What Steve McGuire likes about Calabria:
I often stop by this restaurant for a quick lunch while driving my small bus in the area. The pizza slice is decent, although not the best I've ever had, but certainly not the worst either. I always request it to be extremely hot, as I like it that way. The crust folds up nicely and is crisp. The sauce is good and tangy, not overly sweet. The slices are on the smaller side, so I usually order two. Overall, it's a ver... View all feedback. What S Sylvester doesn't like about Calabria:
There’s an issue with consistency. I had a great pizza from Calabria one day, the next week it was totally different. When the owner isn’t there, the pizza is not the same. Soon as I walked in I could see it wasn’t the same and it wasn’t. Very disappointed. But if the owner is making the pizza that’s a different story. The difference was night and day unfortunately. Service: Dine in View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The pizza at this restaurant is incredibly airy with a delicious bread-like flavor that I enjoy. I didn't feel weighed down after eating it. I also ordered chic...
read moreYou will love it here. Have better orders and less great, but when looking at the general: GREAT.
The owner was so cool nice pizza good food I will recommend if I ever stop
I had gotten two slices of specialty pizza and it was very very good.
Excellent pizza and other take out includingA $29.00 Dinner for 4 take out.
Calabria, a local gem, offers a mixed bag of experiences that ranges from delightful to disappointing. While many patrons praise the pizza's airy texture and the owner's evident passion, inconsistency in quality emerges as a common concern, particularly when the owner isn't present. Customer service also faces criticism, with reports of unsatisfactory resolutions to order issues and low-quality food provided through discount apps. However, several diners laud the restaurant for catering successes and the overall charm of its quick, friendly service. While Calabria shows promise, its fluctuating execution and service challenges may leave some diners hesitant.
The pizza sauce was too sweet, and the pizza was undercooked. The menu options were generic.
The pizza is fantastic, the staff is friendly and very polite! You should definitely try them out if you haven't already!
The food was dry and tasted awful. It did not seem fresh. The pizza was cold and also dry.
Best margarita pie in the area. Love that they're consistent. We've even tried other establishments and always come back. Chicken parm is always fresh.
They make very good pizza. It's hard to get 5 stars in New York for pizza. But I get off the highway for this place. ?
I often stop by this restaurant for a quick lunch while driving my small bus in the area. The pizza slice is decent, although not the best I've ever had, but ce...
read moreI ordered catering for my son's birthday party and received many compliments on the food. The chicken francese and eggplant parmigiana were fantastic. The order...
read moreService: Take out Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Prosciutto, Chicken Francese, Calabria Pizza
This restaurant is a great hidden find, especially amongst the many pizza places in the area. It is definitely the best choice for take-out dinner. The price pe...
read moreThere’s an issue with consistency. I had a great pizza from Calabria one day, the next week it was totally different. When the owner isn’t there, the pizza is n...
read moreI had a great experience at Calabria. I ordered two slices and the service was quick and courteous. The pizza was hot and crispy, I have no complaints. I would...
read moreMy wife and I frequently order from this restaurant and the food is always fantastic! We have tried their pizza, salads, soups, and pasta dishes, and they are a...
read moreI ordered through "Too Good to Waste," an app available in New York that allows customers to try a business at a discounted price. I have used this app several...
read moreTo be clear, I have only stopped in for a slices during lunch. The House pizza is very good, thin crispy crust with no flop, and a good cheese/sauce ratio. Tang...
read more