Poseidon Fish - Sheffield

#24 - Seafood - Sheffield, Fish, Meat

Poseidon Fish

Poseidon Fish
4.0 / 5 (1964 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Poseidon Fish from Sheffield featuring all 4 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

This fish and chip shop had a strong reputation, but recent reviews have been disappointing. Customers have complained of stale chips, thick batter, high prices, and abrupt staff. However, some still found the food delicious, with generous portions and convenient payment options. Overall, while some were let down by the quality and service, others found the experience enjoyable and the food well-cooked. The shop seems to have mixed reviews, with some loyal customers while others are deterred by recent changes.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Paul

Images

Poseidon Fish Food Poseidon Fish Food Poseidon Fish Food Poseidon Fish Food Poseidon Fish Food Poseidon Fish Food Poseidon Fish Food

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 1964 reviews

Was Ione Macgregor at Poseidon Fish a mag?
Our families favourite chippy : I have to say I was quite surprised yo find out they now take card we did a huge detour to find a cash machine, but found out they'd been taking cards for 2 years View all feedback.

What ZsaZsa McKenna-Green dislikes about Poseidon Fish:
This was the best chippy around up until a year ago? We were regulars but not now, since receiving horrible, hard, stale chips on a number of occasions. This spoilt our meal many times having spent over £30 a time that’s just not fair. Why sell stale chips risk your reputation for a few pennies cost is just one maybe two potatoes per person? It should not matter what time of day chips are brought. They should be fres... View all feedback.

jess-july
24.09.2024

Moderate quality, Poor treatment and miserable attitude First of all I must say that the young lady at the counter is very uncomfortable and unfriendly so I felt very inconvenient and it was like a fight, so I am her enemy. The quality doesn’t match the price. Don’t ruin your day with this fish and chips shop.

michael-mayer-office
24.09.2024

These used to be great but they are terrible now. Used to visit regularly but the last three fish and chip suppers have been terrible. Thick batter. Overcooked fish and leathery bits of chips. Very expensive of course now too which makes it even more disappointing. I keep giving them another chance hoping they would improve but they just get worse.

dawn-hayes-forest095
24.09.2024

Go here frequently. Lovely decore, atmosphere service, carpark and best fish and chips I've ever had.

paul-croucher-librar
24.09.2024

Accessible hours, top quality (mostly) fried food

ian-staniforth
24.09.2024

Tried it again after 3yrs,but not improved batter soggy, chips were dry,will not be going again terrible.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.