Reviews - The Milestone
Reviews summary
The Milestone restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere and excellent service, with a menu featuring a variety of choices. While some guests found the food to be average and had a few issues with preparation and presentation, others praised the friendly staff, outstanding service, and great value for money. The cocktails were particularly impressive, and the desserts were worth trying. Some guests did experience slow service and long waiting times, but overall, many enjoyed their meals and are looking forward to returning. While not perfect, The Milestone seems to have potential as a lovely dining option in Sheffield.
Was Anonym at The Milestone a mag?
This establishment is stunning, truly a traditional pub through and through. Savor the flavors of autumn with dishes like Newton Hall from Harleys. This is one of the few places where you can... View all feedback.
What Anonym dislikes about The Milestone:
Eaten here in week and food was lovely, but Sunday lunch was horrible. Dry mashed potato, over crispy roast potatoes and Yorkshire puddings was burnt. Will never have Sunday lunch here again View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 25.11.2022
Eating was very tasty and portions were really decent. not a huge menu (3-4 options per category,) but overall we were made to feel worth and service was in order, but there were some long waiting times (approximately 25 minutes between starter and main - after we finish our starter and about 15 minutes until we actually managed to pay - we tried to catch the attention of one of the waiters.) Price/quality ratio was good, £15pp for a main and a common starter (big sign board for 4ppl.)
The meilenstein would easily get 5 stars if always consistent. sometimes I was and eating was incredible, and then it's still pretty cut. Unfortunately I feel like the restaurant a few years ago at its summit. however, if they use one of the many offers the milestone offers them some great deals to get so worth visiting.
I had an excellent meal, some of the best eating I had for a while. I would definitely book in advance to busy times and I recommend looking at the menu online in advance, as it is limited, so if they don't like one or two things they might be stuck. both eating and service were exemplary and very well treated on the three curses.
What a hidden gem on the island. eating was top notch could not fail it. and the service was off site. we will definitely visit again for another
We have visited many times and always had a warm welcome the food is excellent and the drinks also great choices staff are very knowledgeable happy to recommend
Last update : 12.08.2023
Lovely meal and staff friendly and helpful as usual
Lovely meal, good choice. Ate with my wife who needs to avoid dairy. The advice and service from the staff was outstanding and friendly. The food came promptly and was outstanding and good value for money. Cocktails were fantastic and desserts were well worth the money.
We were bought a voucher for Christmas by our son The meal was brilliant especially the tomato soup The staff were very friendly without being imposing meal was excellent value for money. Will definitely go again
We went on the Yorkshire food guide offer which was unbelievably good value. Lovely food and great service.
Enjoyed the food very much, staff friendly and will go back.
Last update : 25.02.2024
I really love this place and its normally the place I go for dinner on Christmas eve. I have been for about three years on thr un now and have never been...
Came here for Sunday lunch on the August bank holiday weekend. Nice little location. Good menu and ok ish service. Food was alright. However the...
Friendly staff but the food was less than average. The house burger was overcooked and charged with absolutely no flavor whatsoever. What a disappointment.
This establishment is stunning, truly a traditional pub through and through. Savor the flavors of autumn with dishes like Newton Hall from Harleys. This is one of the few places where you can...
The Wellington, previously known as the Cask and Culter, is one of Sheffield's top real ale pubs. Conveniently located near the Shalesmoor tram stop, it is a great option for...
Last update : 27.06.2026
The milestone would easily get 5 stars if was always consistent. Sometimes I’ve been and the food has been incredible and then other times it’s been pretty average. Unfortunately I feel like the restaurant was at its peak a few years ago. However, if you’re using one of the many deals The Milestone offers you can get some great value deals so still worth a visit.
Love this place, atmosphere service. The food has always been really tasty good value. If I'm being really picky, the portions could do with been slightly bigger!
Food was very tasty and portions were really decent. Not a huge menu (3-4 options per category), but Overall we were made to feel valued and service was alright, but there were some long waiting times (about 25mins between starter and main -after we finished our starter- and about 15mins until we actually managed to pay -we were trying to catch the attention of one of the waiters). Value for money was good, £15pp for a main and a shared starter (large charcruterie board for 4ppl).
Went for a team Christmas meal in late December. The food was great but the service was slow 45 mins before we got our starters and almost 1.5 hours before the mains arrived. I didn't particularly mind because we were having a good laugh, but my colleagues who hadn't ordered a starter seriously regretted that choice!
Just been here for a staff do. Absolutely beautiful food. Presentation was incredible. Cooked perfectly. Huge shout out to put waitor/bar staff Dylan. He was polite. Holds a brilliant conversation and is one of the few bar people who can do a real cocktail. This man needs recognition thank you. Would recommend to any one to have a meal there. Wonderful experience.
