Sami's Pizza - Selma

#15 - Pizza - Selma, Sandwiches, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sami's Pizza

Sami's Pizza
3.6 / 5 (213 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Sami's Pizza from Selma includes 79 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $7.3. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Tucked beside a gas station off I-95, Sami’s is a hidden gem serving authentic New York-style pizza and Italian fare in North Carolina. Long praised for its rich flavors and generous portions, Sami’s has earned a loyal following with standout dishes like their large 18-inch pies and chicken parm. While the original family ownership was known for warm hospitality, recent changes in management have led to mixed experiences; some patrons note declines in food quality and service, citing inconsistent staff and atmosphere shifts. Despite this, Sami’s continues to draw fans who appreciate its genuine taste and value, making it a noteworthy stop for pizza enthusiasts.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Steve

Images

Sami's Pizza Food Sami's Pizza Outside Sami's Pizza Menu Sami's Pizza Menu Sami's Pizza Menu

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 213 reviews

Was User at Sami's Pizza a mag?
The food is always better when Dad(owner) is there. There's a real difference in taste when someone else is running the business. Bread is harder, service is slower, etc. Even the New York attitude can be tolerated when the food is this good. View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Sami's Pizza:
I ordered a pizza and an italian hoagie. The meat in the hoagie was not a meat I would recognize in an italian hoagie. I asked if they put oil and vinegar on the hoagie and was told it was italian dressing which would have been ok but it came with mayonnaise on it, which is unacceptable. I will never order from here again. Don't waste your money on a subpar pizza. View all feedback.

I worked here last year. The managers don't know what they're doing and have no idea how to properly train the staff. They and a few of my ex-coworkers were sometimes rude to the customers. The managers like to yell at their employees when something goes wrong and you haven't done anything. The orders take forever, and a good amount of the food is not fresh. The garlic knots, the canolis, and some of the other stuff were frozen I believe. I've had their pizza and garlic knots before. The pizza was OK and the garlic knots weren't garlicy enough for my taste. It's definitely not worth the price they're asking. And if you get harassed by an employee, the managers don't do anything about it. Service for the most part is pretty slow. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. You're better off going somewhere else that has good service and food.

I ordered a pizza and an italian hoagie. The meat in the hoagie was not a meat I would recognize in an italian hoagie. I asked if they put oil and vinegar on the hoagie and was told it was italian dressing which would have been ok but it came with mayonnaise on it, which is unacceptable. I will never order from here again. Don't waste your money on a subpar pizza.

Love it The pizza is very cheeseeeee and the subs is the best I have ever had . The staff is very Friendly

steve-n-jessica
19.03.2025

So much better now that the new Italian owners have taken over and they have free delivery to Princeton!

tom-goffe
19.03.2025

Hint: it is New York style pizza ala Arthur Avenue, not some Golden Corral junk. If you understand real pizza and Big Apple Italian food, you’ll feel right at home. Save yourself a 400 mile road trip Sami’s is the real deal.

Full Menu

  • Rolls And Stromboli

    Ham, Pepperoni And Salami Roll
    Ham, Pepperoni And Salami Roll
    $7.5
    Ham, Pepperoni And Salami Stromboli
    Ham, Pepperoni And Salami Stromboli
    $7.5
  • Dessert

    Chocolate Cage
    Chocolate Cage
    $3.5
  • Perri'S Original Huge Slice

    White Garlic Slice
    White Garlic Slice
    $2.2

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.