Images
ContributeFeedback
Contribute Feedback What Libby W likes about Trophy Pizza:
Everything is SO GOOD, even when delivered all the way across town. It's so hard to find mozz sticks that hold up after sitting in a car for 30 mins or whatever, but these were still crispy and gooey. Loved the east coast style pizza. Will def order again. View all feedback.
What Mitch M doesn't like about Trophy Pizza:
Called two different phone numbers for this place. No answer at all.Checked the website. Four square says it's expired.Looks like this place is PERMANENTLY CLOSED.That or they don't care if you frequent the joint. View all feedback.
Called two different phone numbers for this place. No answer at all.Checked the website. Four square says it's expired.Looks like this place is PERMANENTLY CLOSED.That or they don't care if you frequent the joint.
Today I went in for a slice of Cheese Pie but I have tried pretty much everything they offer on the menu. First off, this place shares the same venue as Burb's Burger (which is amazing . So you can if you want order a slice of pizza from Trophy and an order of French Fries from Burbs. Service is very consistently solid. They do get super busy during game days so they cannot always be super attentive but on most days, I would say the service is excellent. Over the last year or so, they expanded the seating area. So you can now actually order and sit down to consume your food (or drinks if you want to! . They also offer a very nice outdoor seating area. Their pizzas are very good. East Coast style pizza. Each slice isn't massive or anything but the price is pretty reasonable (3.50 for a slice of cheese pie . Just like more places in NY, they have the pizza already premade but they heat it up for you before serving. One thing to note is if you want to order a whole pie, you may want to call in ahead of time. It may take some time for them to make one for you. They only accept credit cards (no cash .
Cheap quick and okay. If you're not looking for a high quality pizza but in a hurry and just want a slice, trophy's is where you go. The lady behind the counter was pretty rude didn't make eye contact and made me feel like I was a burden to be ordering pizza. Also pretty confusing to find, for this location is inside and not listed from the outside. We thought it was closed down at first and replaced with another eatery.
If you want to sit inside, it 's 21 and over only. Just FYI, since we were staying in a nearby hotel with our child and had to take our pizza back there to eat it. The server told me this fact only after I had ordered and he had served me a beer. So I took that to go too. A minor open container law violation, but we evaded the authorities and arrived safely to our hotel to consume pizza (for both) and beer for me. Kiddo had cheese and I had a slice of pepperoni (smaller crispy delicious spicy discs of pep and wonderful crunchy yet chewy dough). The slice are big and affordable and have that wood fired thing going on. Aside from the not being able to eat there because it 's was 21 and over it was a great space. If I was going to a game, it would be a great spot to grab some good grub that is not a ballpark overpriced nightmare.
We are from out of town. Google this place they had good reviews. They close and 9 and NO WHERE on the website does it say the kitchens closed and 8. We came for pizze and all they had was cheese and one other by the slice. They told us the kitchen wouldn't make us a pizza due to they close in ten minutes. All they had to do in cook some pepperoni and then put them on the cheese slices. But I guess some people can't think out of the box.