Petoskey's - Seattle

American, Pizza, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Petoskey's

Petoskey's
2.4 / 5 (366 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Petoskey's from Seattle includes 50 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $13.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Nestled in the heart of the Midwest, this charming eatery offers a delightful mix of classic tavern favorites and friendly service, making it an ideal spot for both casual lunches and lively evenings. Guests appreciate the welcoming atmosphere, though some have reported long wait times for food, particularly during busier moments. While the menu boasts delicious pizza and burgers, staffing shortages can lead to delays. Despite occasional hiccups, the warm hospitality from bartenders and engaging staff, along with the dog-friendly environment, keeps patrons coming back for more. Overall, it’s a gem for anyone craving genuine Midwest cuisine.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Mike

Images

Petoskey's Food Petoskey's Food Petoskey's Food Petoskey's Food Petoskey's Menu Petoskey's Food Petoskey's Food Petoskey's Menu

Feedback

★ 2.4 / 5 from 366 reviews

Was Jacob M at Petoskey's a mag?
I have visited this restaurant three times and I have really enjoyed it. It is quieter than most, which I appreciate, and there is always a seat available with easy service. I recently tried their pizza and it was delicious. If you enjoy thin crust pizza, this is the place to go. They also have a restaurant section for families. View all feedback.

What Danielle Petrey dislikes about Petoskey's:
To the bartender in the glasses please wait to take shots until there is no line waiting for drinks or food…it sucks to find out five min after ordering you’re out of wings or poutine during game View all feedback.

There are no longer any vegan options available, so I would not recommend this restaurant.

aaron-1220
09.08.2023

I tried the poutine at this restaurant and I really liked it. The atmosphere was nice, the pizza oven was impressive, and the Midwestern vibes were evident. It may seem a bit tucked away, but I would definitely recommend this place to both locals and tourists.

zachariah-25
09.08.2023

I have yet to try something at this random bar restaurant with reasonable prices that I haven't enjoyed. The food is really good! I do wish they still had the beet salad on their limited quarantine menu.

mike-t-library4
02.10.2024

Wow! What an incredible find. After spending three years in Seattle, I’ve been on the lookout for a good deli, and while this isn’t a traditional deli, the Italian hoagie I had was the best I’ve tasted in the city. The meat was top-notch, paired perfectly with oil and vinegar, and those little momma's peppers added a wonderful kick. It was absolutely delicious! The tater tots as a side were a fantastic addition, and the ambiance was really nice. I can’t believe I’ve lived just a mile away and never visited before. The cherry on top is that it’s a Vikings bar that shows the games. As a Vikings fan, this will definitely become my new go-to spot on Sundays!

shawn-wright
02.10.2024

Nice hoagie for Seattle. Bread was good, but I do wish that they would have scooped some out. Ordered the Italian and held the mayo.

  • Supper

    Bouja
    Bouja
    $9.1
    Petoskey Burger
    Petoskey Burger
    $15.2
    2 Klement's Wisconsin Brats
    2 Klement's Wisconsin Brats
    $13.1
    Petoskey's Mac' N Cheese
    Petoskey's Mac' N Cheese
    $13.1
  • Pizza

    Petoskey's Big Mac' N Cheese
    Petoskey's Big Mac' N Cheese
    $20.2
    General Moses
    General Moses
    $21.2

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.