Reviews
What Brian A. Becker likes about Gino's Of Sayville:
I have never been disappointed when ordering from here! It's one of the few places that knows how to make a well-done pizza perfectly—crispy just as it should be! The garlic knots are incredible as well. Since moving to Sayville a few months ago, this has become my go-to spot for pizza. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 View all feedback.
What william devine doesn't like about Gino's Of Sayville:
I ordered takeout for lunch and found the experience to be quite disappointing. Priced between $20 to $30 per person, the food was lackluster and didn't meet expectations, earning a rating of 2 out of 5. The service was also underwhelming, with a similar rating of 2. The overall atmosphere left much to be desired, again landing at a 2. Unfortunately, this meal did not live up to the price point, and I would not recom... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Absolutely the best pizza on Long Island! I dined in for dinner and the price per person was just $1-10, which is an incredible deal. The food was outstanding—d...
read moreI have never been disappointed when ordering from here! It's one of the few places that knows how to make a well-done pizza perfectly—crispy just as it should b...
read moreService: Take out Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Grandma Pie
I ordered takeout for lunch and found the experience to be quite disappointing. Priced between $20 to $30 per person, the food was lackluster and didn't meet ex...
read moreJust picked up my pizza. So disappointed . I was really looking forward to it too. Shame. OK. They righted their wrong and my second pizza was yummy! Thanks. Fo...
read moreI ordered the Grandma Slice, a Neapolitan (Regular) Slice, and a Deep Dish Slice, all with pepperoni, and I can confidently say that all three are among the bes...
read moreI ordered a Neapolitan (Regular) Pie well done, and it was amazing! Absolutely delicious! I moved to Long Island 26 years ago, and this is by far the best pizza...
read moreDelicious food and excellent service! I made a special request after placing my order, and the staff member I spoke with was very friendly and handled everythin...
read moreThe Vegan Grandma Pie was amazing. Everything from here is delicious. The vegan menu is big and everything is so good. I ordered a whole pie to take home since...
read moreChicken tasted like rubber. Extremely disappointed.