Tobey's Pizza - Sandy Lake

Stopped by on my way home. Got the steak hoagie: delicious! Nice, clean, friendly little place with good food for my first visit.

I eat at Tobeys very much always clean and taste super, good price when someone says they are not fresh, they do not know what is fresh! The steak is delicious...

Tobey has the most amazing Steak-Hoagies and Wedgies. I could eat them every day.

Driven past Tobey's countless times, finally decided to stop and try it. Overall the pizza was good. I got a Station Square size pizza with pepperoni and a small cheese pizza. Both pizzas came with a generous portion of cheese, no need to order extra cheese. The crust was nothing special, but still good. The only real critique I would make was the sauce had a slight spaghetti-o flavor. But, from what I can tell Tobey's has been around for awhile so maybe the sauce flavor is a local taste preference. If that's the case then I totally get it. For sure I'll be back again and would encourage others to try it. Prior to writing this review I did read through the past reviews and wanted to address some of the lame complaints. First off, yes they only take cash. I also didn't realize that but DIRECTLY across the street is a bank with a 24 ATM, plus less then a block away is a gas station with an ATM and you can get cash back on purchases. Secondly, the pizza did not taste like cardboard. That's such a lame cliche thing to say about pizza. Lastly, the people working there where not going to win congeniality awards but they were perfectly friendly. When I stopped in I was coming from work and was totally covered with sweat, dirt, and grease. I'm sure I was off putting to the older gray haired lady behind the counter but she was still friendly.

Still awesome subs! Everyone there is super nice. We were passing through so we ordered and waited in the back of the building at the picnic table under a lovely tree. Thanks!