Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What ChevelleCarcass likes about Tortuga Sandwich Shop:
Just stopped out for a Sammy after seeing so much goodness posted on FB. WOW, is all I have to say, sooo much flavor, everything was fresh and the Sandwhichnista was very nice. Gonna come back again for sure!!! View all feedback.
An absolute gem. The combinations are brilliant reimaginings of a number of street foods you can 't find in Buffalo. We 've tried over half the menu and many specials in the last year and honestly, some are instant classics (looking at you, Pepe) and othersare simply among the most delicious sandwiches you 'll find in the area. You can 't go wrong.
At this point, I?ve had almost every sandwich on the menu. All excellent. Banger after banger. The sides are great too! Awesome food, good, kind service, five easy stars.
The hype is real! Finally stopped here having driven by a 100 times. Actually drove past again, then turned around. Glad I did. Ordered the Gustavo and it was very delicious, and cleverly wrapped to make eating it easier. The place was clean, cool musicand relatively fast service. The side of coleslaw was nice too. Try it out!!!
Delicious food, made fresh while you wait! The chicken is amazing (Brasa). Everything here looks sounds good- wish I had a bigger stomach lol. Cute glass bottled beverages, old school memories. Friendly wait staff who makes sure you have everythingyou need. We will be back!! I would definitely recommend Tortuga!
Wonderful shop in Sanborn. Got the chili to with chips. Very tasty sandwich. My only complaint was there was a little fat on the edge of the ribeye that I thought should have been trimmed off. Also got a slice of the cake to take home. OMG it is soooogood. Overall highly recommend.