Reviews
What Rotherhamgirl doesn't like about Sitwell Arms:
Came here on a Friday night with a group of girls from work. The food was lovely and I found it excellent value for money. I had the small fish and chips and then the chocolate brownie with ice cream. The two young servers behind the bar were lovely, but they were being treated awfully by the assistant manager. We didn’t quite get her name but she was a small women with brunette hair, who was talking to her staff wit... View all feedback. What Leah C likes about Sitwell Arms:
Absolutely amazing carvery made by Michelle, came today with family and everything was absolutely beautiful, the stuffing balls are to die for, the meat is so tender and the vegetables are homemade and taste amazing, the staff are all really friendly especially kirstie, she was so lovely, will definitely come more often! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Wrong information given with menus, said only skinny fries were available, till said that was wrong and they had mash and chunky chips. Food arrived with soggy...
read moreVisited Fri with friends I ordered curry it was beef although well presented with rice nan poppadom the curry sauce was very watery and un appealing cant recomm...
read moreWe ordered 3 meals today for lunch and waited 55 minutes for them. On arrival, it was very poor quality. Chips appeared to have been re-heated, the peas were pa...
read moreI had the classic burger my friend is vegan she had the chick pea curry both meals beautiful and staff are so nice and helpful. The atmosphere is lovely warm an...
read moreWent here yesterday with anticipation not knowing what the covid restrictions would bring, but i need not worryThe staff, the host, and the organisation was fan...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe Sitwell Arms boasts a varied dining experience that resonates with some patrons for its excellent value, friendly service, and a commendable menu. Guests have praised the succulent carvery and delightful fish and chips, often highlighting the attentive staff and their ability to handle challenging situations with grace. However, recent reviews reveal concerns about inconsistent food quality and service, particularly under new management. Some diners experienced disorganization and unappetizing meals, prompting disappointment. Despite mixed feedback, the ambiance and commitment to cleanliness continue to attract visitors. A revival of its former charm may yet win back its loyal clientele.
The food at this pub lunch carvery was delicious. Everything was cooked perfectly, from the crunchy cabbage to the delicious beef. The atmosphere on the "upper...
read moreThe food was good, but the wait time was unacceptable! Especially with two children in tow. Unfortunately, we won't be returning.
After a disappointing first visit to Sitwell, we were encouraged to give them another chance. What a difference this time! The food was delicious as always, but...
read moreBooked a table for 5 of us, we had a lovely spacious table. The staff are so friendly and helpful , 4 of us had the carvery which was brilliant such a good vari...
read moreCalled in for Sunday lunch carvery , had a drink and was soon found a table , first class service and the food was excellent .
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more