Justin's Pizza - Riverview

#16 - Pizza - Riverview, Italian, Salad
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Justin's Pizza

Justin's Pizza
4.4 / 5 (1571 reviews)

Menu

The place from Riverview offers 77 different menus and drinks on the menu at an average price of $12.2.

Nestled in Brandon, this restaurant has garnered attention for its standout pizza and wings, drawing both locals and visitors alike. While some have faced issues with service and order accuracy, many rave about the flavorful Quattro Formaggio pizza, citing its rich cheese and quality crust reminiscent of New York style. Most agree that the wings also impress, showcasing bold flavors. Despite occasional inconsistencies, the friendly atmosphere and evident staff passion make it a popular choice. Those in search of excellent, non-franchise pizza will find this spot worth the journey, even if they encounter a few minor hiccups.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Holly

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1571 reviews

Was Cassandra Bergstrom at Justin's Pizza a mag?
One of the best pizzas I've ever had, they were recommended to me and I will definitely be a regular from now on, I also tried the wings with hot sauce and I can say they are excellent. Keep up the good work and quality View all feedback.

What Carson Reichel dislikes about Justin's Pizza:
To start prices were more then listed online. So I was getting old menu. Fine so be it. Wanted 10 wings but 2 sauces. Guy said I had to order 2 6's for 2 sauces. Didnt argue on price just payed it. Got home and 6 wings in one and 5 wings in other. So payed $4 more for 2 6 pieces (2 wings) and then get short one. Pizza was dry, limited sauce. Cheese was pretty thin. Will not visit again. Only reason for 2 stars is the... View all feedback.

bhatta-tulsi
10.09.2022

Born and raised in brooklyn I grew up on eating NYC style pizza? this disc let me forget that I was in fl? the perfect NYC disc is hard to get out of the condition not here tho!

carson39
10.09.2022

To start prices were more then listed online. So I was getting old menu. Fine so be it. Wanted 10 wings but 2 sauces. Guy said I had to order 2 6's for 2 sauces. Didnt argue on price just payed it. Got home and 6 wings in one and 5 wings in other. So payed $4 more for 2 6 pieces (2 wings) and then get short one. Pizza was dry, limited sauce. Cheese was pretty thin. Will not visit again. Only reason for 2 stars is the ELEVEN wings were good.

lexie-bashirian
10.09.2022

Not from around here wanted to try a different pizza place other than dominoes and Pizza Hut. It was yummy! Definitely would buy here again

gbergnaum-student702
10.09.2022

Literally the best pizza place no joke, their pizza is amazing, their wings are amazing, their stromboli is amazing, literally everything is amazing though they are quite far away but it's worth the drive

astrosin-snake5133
10.09.2022

Best NY style pizza around, great service.

  • Gourmet Pizzas (Available In 14", 16" & 18")

    Our Famous Tampa Tower Pizza
    Our Famous Tampa Tower Pizza

    (AKA the kerin realty pizza) Meatball; peperoni; sausage; cheese & supreme.

    $69.5
  • Specialties

    Pizzaturnover
    Pizzaturnover

    Mozzarella Cheese & sauce

    $9.9
  • Hot Subs

    6 Cheese Steak Special
    6 Cheese Steak Special
    $7.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.