Sergio's - Riverhead
Sergio's
Menu
A complete menu of Sergio's from Riverhead featuring all 16 menus and drinks can be found here on the menu.
Sergio’s in Riverhead offers a blend of New York and Italian-style pizza that many patrons rave as some of the best around. The staff is often praised for their warmth and helpfulness, creating a welcoming atmosphere for both newcomers and longtime fans alike. Signature items like garlic knots and meat lover’s pies are frequently highlighted. However, some customers report inconsistent experiences with delivery times, food temperature, and service attitude. While the in-person dining experience is generally positive, improvements in order accuracy and customer care could elevate Sergio’s reputation even further.
Images
Feedback
Was Antonio Valenciano at Sergio's a mag?
Honestly this is the best pizza I ever tried before. The New York style combined with Italian style; plus the gourmet selection make this place just amazing.Can't wait to order again!!! View all feedback.
What judy watkins dislikes about Sergio's:
If you would like three meatballs cut up on a 12-in sub go ahead and pay $10.99 and then three slices of salami very thin three slices of pepperoni maybe four, and one slice of provolone cut in half one on each side and a whole bunch of salad on top you might enjoy it but I did not and I love Sergio's on my life View all feedback.
I love sergios pizza we have been ordering since I was little
So me and my family been going to Sergios for years, but since the new girl started working “Nicole” I Know her name because I’ve heard it several times from the coworkers. But the Quality isn’t the same almost every time I’ve been there since she’s been working everything I order is burnt or undercooked Simply not up to their regular Expectations. She is super rude and honestly looks dirty more times then once And I really try to order one. I know she isn’t working. On occasions, there were some one who came in looking for her And I was just so disgusted and disbelief because isn’t this a work establishment? I’ll be back just now when she’s there!!!!!
Pass on this one unless your looking for a step above domino's
I'm always satisfied and filled with happiness when I enjoy this pizza, whether I pick it up or have it delivered. The delivery is consistently quick, and the pizza arrives piping hot! The crust is absolutely delightful, the staff is friendly, and their consistency keeps me coming back for more!
We waited over an hour for the food which wouldn't be bad except for the fact that the Pizza was burnt and dry, the garlic knots were cold and the calzone was so doughy and undercooked. Just trying to enjoy a movie night with the wife but instead we're trying to find another place to eat.
Full Menu
Sides
Salads
Meat Dishes
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
Chicken Wings
More information
QR-Code for the menu
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.3 / 5 (1607 reviews)#39 Seafood in Riverhead BarsDark Horse
East Main Street 1, 11901 Riverhead, US
"Very fine wait staff! They really took good care of me"
★ 4.4 / 5 (2619 reviews)#26 Mexican in Riverhead SeafoodTweeds Buffalo Bar
17 E Main StNY 11901, Riverhead, United States
"Steak and lamb chops was undercooked and over seasoned"
★ 4.5 / 5 (4475 reviews)#1 Vegetarian in Riverhead AmericanFriendly's
Old Country Road 949, 11901 Riverhead, US
"It was very nice!!We love new mini mozz sticks!!"