Sergio's - Riverhead
Sergio's
Description
Sergio’s in Riverhead offers a blend of New York and Italian-style pizza that many patrons rave as some of the best around. The staff is often praised for their warmth and helpfulness, creating a welcoming atmosphere for both newcomers and longtime fans alike. Signature items like garlic knots and meat lover’s pies are frequently highlighted. However, some customers report inconsistent experiences with delivery times, food temperature, and service attitude. While the in-person dining experience is generally positive, improvements in order accuracy and customer care could elevate Sergio’s reputation even further.
Images
Feedback
I'm always satisfied and filled with happiness when I enjoy this pizza, whether I pick it up or have it delivered. The delivery is consistently quick, and the pizza arrives piping hot! The crust is absolutely delightful, the staff is friendly, and their consistency keeps me coming back for more!
We waited over an hour for the food which wouldn't be bad except for the fact that the Pizza was burnt and dry, the garlic knots were cold and the calzone was so doughy and undercooked. Just trying to enjoy a movie night with the wife but instead we're trying to find another place to eat.
I ordered the Veal Cutlet Parm meal, which came with garlic knots and a side salad. The veal was incredibly tender—it could be cut with a fork! The sauce was fantastic! We decided to share one meal between my wife and me, and it was more than enough for both of us. We've been ordering from Sergio's for nearly five years. If you're looking for home-cooked meals, this is the place to go! For cheap fast food, you can always opt for Domino's or Pizza Hut. But if you want authentic Italian food, this is the real deal!
Been ordering here for a while food is good people are nice but I always ask them to make my pies thin and crispy/well done. I don’t like floppy crust. They never get it right. It’s always under cooked. I’m tired of asking them to make it well done. Time to find a new place. Sorry but how hard is it to make a crust well done!!
Everything is cool the Spanish gentleman was helping me out until that lady she didn't even ask me what is my order not even saying thank you she actually just leaving on the table and I have to grab it myself it's not about the Stars it's about how to serve the people the lady was waiting for her order she looks at me and I told her I will never come back here again unless she is not here anymore
Menu
Sides
Salads
Meat Dishes
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
Chicken Wings
Menu PDF
FAQ
More information
QR-Code for the menu
