Reviews - Sweeney Todd Pie Shop

I first sampled a Sweeney Todd pie in the 1980s. I rarely come to Reading so top of my list of things to do was to have a pie at Sweeney’s and work the rest of... read more I first sampled a Sweeney Todd pie in the 1980s. I rarely come to Reading so top of my list of things to do was to have a pie at Sweeney’s and work the rest of the itinerary around that. My boeuf bourguignon pie did not disappoint. A lovely proper pie, i.e. base and top, with a filling that matched its name. We shared a ratatouille as a side which went well with the pies. This is a surviving independent, their pies are one of the few things you can get in Reading that you can only get in Reading. They serve good ale too. My highlight of the day.

If it’s pies you are after then this is the place to go. What a selection of beautifully made delicious pies and lovely sides. A pie and a side each is more tha... read more If it’s pies you are after then this is the place to go. What a selection of beautifully made delicious pies and lovely sides. A pie and a side each is more than plenty. Each pie is well constructed and jam packed full of ingredients. I had chicken and ham and it was packed with meat. With cauliflower cheese on the side and I was stuffed. Restaurant is full of character and friendly staff. Don’t come here if you want fine dining but if you want brilliant traditional food served in a place that’s been here for years then don’t hesitate. Can’t recommend it enough

Great pies, old school restaurant that has character, lovely staff. For over 45 years open and struggling with chain “restaurants” taking over and the expense o... read more Great pies, old school restaurant that has character, lovely staff. For over 45 years open and struggling with chain “restaurants” taking over and the expense of everything these days. Survived covid. Decent people making amazing real food. It should have local support. Once a place like this with incredible character and true real food is gone, it’s gone forever. Keep it alive and enjoy the best pies you will ever have. Use it or lose it.

First time I have been here the occasion was a friends birthday great atmosphere and very well priced enjoyed the experience read more First time I have been here the occasion was a friends birthday great atmosphere and very well priced enjoyed the experience

Perfectly kept pint as usual, friendly service and the pies are as good as ever. Harvey’s Best, Butcombe Bitter or Proper Job make a fine selection of ales. Pie... read more Perfectly kept pint as usual, friendly service and the pies are as good as ever. Harvey’s Best, Butcombe Bitter or Proper Job make a fine selection of ales. Pie with cauliflower cheese, then proper pudding with custard, all at a reasonable price. It’s a pleasure to support this gem, Reading’s finest.

Hadn't been to Sweeneys for about 18 years since moving out of the area but visited last night and it hasn't changed one bit! Still does the best pies... read more Hadn't been to Sweeneys for about 18 years since moving out of the area but visited last night and it hasn't changed one bit! Still does the best pies...

I have been coming to this restaurant for more than 30 years. Hopefully, this speaks volumes about how much I love this place! The pies are amazing and full of... read more I have been coming to this restaurant for more than 30 years. Hopefully, this speaks volumes about how much I love this place! The pies are amazing and full of delicious flavors.

Don't be fooled by this place. Has to be the best pie I've ever had. Wonderful staff too. Be good if you go to this place read more Don't be fooled by this place. Has to be the best pie I've ever had. Wonderful staff too. Be good if you go to this place

Brilliant pie and great service from the lovely staff as usual! : D read more Brilliant pie and great service from the lovely staff as usual! : D

Amazing pies and excellent service! It really made me feel like I was back up North. Thank you! :D read more Amazing pies and excellent service! It really made me feel like I was back up North. Thank you! :D

The restaurant offers an impressive selection of real ales and definitely boasts the largest cakes you’ll ever find. The staff is friendly and accommodating, ad... read more The restaurant offers an impressive selection of real ales and definitely boasts the largest cakes you’ll ever find. The staff is friendly and accommodating, adding to the experience. The atmosphere is lovely and cozy, making it a delightful place to enjoy your time.

Delicious cake! I tried several varieties, and they were even better when warmed up. I will definitely return for more! read more Delicious cake! I tried several varieties, and they were even better when warmed up. I will definitely return for more!

Best cake in Reading! Has a lot of history, and the grandma reading the menu was great. A family business that continues to deliver. Unbelievable place to go if... read more Best cake in Reading! Has a lot of history, and the grandma reading the menu was great. A family business that continues to deliver. Unbelievable place to go if you want cake, incredible selection I can't say.

I didn't actually dine in the restaurant, but the takeaway cakes are far superior to anything you'll find in a supermarket. read more I didn't actually dine in the restaurant, but the takeaway cakes are far superior to anything you'll find in a supermarket.

Award-winning cakes and quirky buildings. A huge selection of in-house baked cakes, and the cakes are massive themselves. I had venison, cherry and leek - a per... read more Award-winning cakes and quirky buildings. A huge selection of in-house baked cakes, and the cakes are massive themselves. I had venison, cherry and leek - a perfect balance of flavors in a rich engraving and ordered 2 pages to share with my husband. The cauliflower cheese had a delicious sauce and grilled to crack the cheese tip, and wide beans made the perfect compliment to a hearty meal. Very recommended!