Casey's - Random Lake

American, North American, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19209948097

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Casey's from Random Lake featuring all 1 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Casey's in Random Lake, WI, is a beloved American restaurant with a focus on delivering a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, including plenty of vegetarian options. Open from 5:00 AM to 9:00 PM, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a meal at any time of day. To ensure you have a seat, we recommend calling ahead to reserve your table at (920) 994-8097. Don't miss the chance to experience what Casey's has to offer—leave a review after your visit and share your thoughts! If you're interested in similar dining experiences, check out Kathy's 111 Trackside Cafe and Midway Eat for more delightful options.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Cordelia

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Outside Casey's Menu Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food

Feedback

★ 2.6 / 5 from 144 reviews

Despite its potential, this restaurant suffers from poor management that hinders staff performance and overall efficiency. Frequent closures and inconsistent service plague the experience, although customers rave about the friendly and dedicated team members who strive to provide excellent service. While the pizza tends to be on the pricier side, the quick online ordering and punctual food preparation stand out. A notable incident of personalized customer care highlights the positive aspects amidst challenges. Overall, the establishment needs managerial improvement to reach its full potential.

hlittel-1
Gerald 29.03.2023 - 07:31

I love how convenient this gas station is but sadly it has gone down hill the last few months. I've stopped to buy alcohol and they were unable to sell it. They don't have online ordering available and the kitchen has been closed often. They also don't restock items as often as the Casey's store miles down the road do. I'm not sure what's up but it's worrisome and disappointing.

maurine74
Maurine 29.03.2023 - 07:31

They may have given the store a makeover but it definitely is still making me wish it was a Kwik trip. I?d like to see management take some pride in this location.

wcrist-3
Elsie 27.02.2025 - 14:00

There's always something lately kitchen closed, can't sell alcohol, kitchen closed a lot.... Will not stop anymore, Caseys right down the road in Fredonia.

cordelia-goyette
Cordelia 27.02.2025 - 14:00

This place needs new management. Everyone blames the other employees but it boils down to management. How can anyone do a job without a good shift leader and store managers and their regional aka trainers. Every time I've seen a manager, they're onlysitting in a room doing nothing.

okeefe-shanny
Shanny 27.02.2025 - 14:00

While their pizza is quite pricey for some reason, the customer service was excellent. The young woman who worked there was not only beautiful but also had a lovely smile and knew how to deliver outstanding service.

Full Menu

  • These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.