Reviews
What User likes about Reel:
Every visit to this restaurant has been enjoyable, but the New Year's Eve party really exceeded our expectations! It was truly amazing. The decorations were beautiful, the atmosphere felt cozy, and the food was outstanding. Andy, Angela, and the rest of the staff did a fantastic job with the food, and everyone was so welcoming and friendly. We hope that this will become a long-standing tradition for us. Thank you for... View all feedback. What Sarah M doesn't like about Reel:
We have been visiting this restaurant for years, but unfortunately, the prices have increased significantly and the food quality has declined. There are superior dining options elsewhere on the island. We do not recommend it. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
We have had great experiences during every visit, but the New Year's Eve party absolutely exceeded our expectations! The decorations were lovely, the atmosphere...
read moreWe discovered our new favorite dining spot on the island! You must try the shrimp tacos - they were amazing! The service was also fantastic, which is a rare fin...
read moreThe food was fantastic!! Our party of 6 all thoroughly enjoyed our meals. From the shrimp and perch tacos to the mussels, nachos, and deep-fried pickles, everyt...
read moreThere is something about the Reel Burger that makes the trip to Put In Bay worth it! The food is excellent:
One of my favorite places to hang out on the island. The fish tacos are delicious, the beer selection is great, service is always friendly. The Ray Fogg show is...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreNestled on the island, this restaurant offers a mix of experiences that leave guests divided. While some loyal patrons lament rising prices and declining food quality, others rave about exceptional moments, particularly during festive events like the New Year's Eve party, which boasts cozy decor and outstanding cuisine. The shrimp tacos have emerged as a standout favorite, celebrated for their deliciousness alongside other menu highlights. With friendly service and a lively atmosphere, many consider it a must-visit dining spot. Despite some concerns, the restaurant stands out as a cherished place for gathering and enjoying memorable meals.
We had a fantastic experience at this restaurant, with delicious food. Be sure to save room for the neighboring places as well. We all enjoyed our time there an...
read moreThe food and drinks were delicious! We especially enjoyed the lobster roll, and the service was outstanding.
We have been visiting this restaurant for years, but unfortunately, the prices have increased significantly and the food quality has declined. There are superio...
read moreReally great find and drinks! The pickle shot was so fun! The server was really knowledgeable about gluten allergies as well!
Great food great service. Bria was superb wonderful. Anytime I'm in town will come back.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreEvery visit to this restaurant has been enjoyable, but the New Year's Eve party really exceeded our expectations! It was truly amazing. The decorations were bea...
read moreWe discovered our new favorite dining spot on the island! Be sure to try the shrimp tacos - they are delicious. The service was excellent as well, which is a ra...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more