Upper Deck - Put in Bay

The service at this restaurant is outstanding. We had Blake as our server, and he was incredibly knowledgeable about the best places to visit on the island. The... read more The service at this restaurant is outstanding. We had Blake as our server, and he was incredibly knowledgeable about the best places to visit on the island. The food is absolutely a must-try! There is plenty...

The food was tasty, but there weren't many chicken options on the menu. The servers caught us off guard; we ordered a pitcher and were shocked to see the price—... read more The food was tasty, but there weren't many chicken options on the menu. The servers caught us off guard; we ordered a pitcher and were shocked to see the price—$66.50! That was definitely unexpected for us...

The $29.99 lobster sandwich, touted as an island favorite, was a complete disappointment. It will definitely go down in history for being the worst. There was b... read more The $29.99 lobster sandwich, touted as an island favorite, was a complete disappointment. It will definitely go down in history for being the worst. There was barely any lobster, and it was completely lacking in flavor.

We had the best lobster we've ever tasted! The New England lobster was packed with meat and absolutely delicious. We dined on the outdoor deck, which offered a... read more We had the best lobster we've ever tasted! The New England lobster was packed with meat and absolutely delicious. We dined on the outdoor deck, which offered a stunning view. The shrimp and crab pizza was also fantastic. There was a touch of frozen bisque provided for later, which was a nice treat. The service was excellent as well.

The best lobster bisque I’ve ever had! Their lobster rolls are fantastic, and the beer is served ice cold. The staff is friendly, and the view is delightful. It... read more The best lobster bisque I’ve ever had! Their lobster rolls are fantastic, and the beer is served ice cold. The staff is friendly, and the view is delightful. It’s like a little piece of paradise in Ohio.