Proctor Pizza Sub Shop

Pizza, Cheese, Tacos
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Proctor Pizza Sub Shop

Proctor Pizza Sub Shop
4.5 / 5 (610 reviews)

Description

At Proctor Pizza, patrons rave about the exceptional service and inviting atmosphere, creating a welcoming experience for all. The menu boasts a wide variety, with many declaring the pizza among the best they’ve ever tasted—crafted from fresh ingredients and perfect dough. However, feedback indicates inconsistencies in food quality and presentation, with some dishes lacking flavor and requiring improvements in packaging, notably moving away from Styrofoam. While many commend the customer service and the overall dining experience, there are calls for enhancements to ensure consistency and sustainability without compromising the quality that keeps guests coming back for more.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Rick

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 610 reviews
rick-mcarthur
15.10.2024

Very good pizza and friendly staff

charlie-o-forest46
15.10.2024

Friendly staff and decent portions.

joshua-spikberg-2
15.10.2024

An amazing small town eatery, the food is excellent, never disappoints. Excellent photos of history in the railroad industry to look at while you wait for your food. If you havent eaten here you should definitely put on the list to try out!

yvonne-fredrickson
15.10.2024

Very good chicken bacon wrap. Price was great and the service was wonderful! I would definitely stop again if I am in the area

kayla-riley-engineer
15.10.2024

Local business! Staff is super friendly, I like the option to get the unbaked pizza, and their toppings are always so fresh and never skimpy. I haven't tried their subs or wraps yet, but the pizza is top notch!

FAQ

The restaurant and its rooms are wheelchair accessible and thus reachable with a wheelchair or physical limitations.

The restaurant also takes various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.