Casey's - Princeton

American, North American, Delivery Services

Casey's

Casey's
2.8 / 5 (123 reviews)

Description

Dining at this Casey's location was marked by frustrating delays and poor service. Guests experienced extended wait times, with some waiting over two hours for their orders, only to receive incorrect or subpar pizzas. Communication proved inadequate; repeated calls about their orders yielded little reassurance or apology. The reward program, intended to enhance the experience, also fell short, as customers found it unusable for their purchases. Overall, this establishment seems in dire need of improvements in both service efficiency and customer satisfaction, as patrons vowed to seek alternatives for their pizza needs in the future.

Last update: 27.03.2026 from: Roderick

Feedback

★ 2.8 / 5 from 123 reviews
roderick34
27.10.2022

Terrible terrible terrible. Ordered a simple cheese pizza. Delivery said it would take 1 hour and 30 minutes. Longer than I wanted, but oh well. Order put in at 6:20. It?s 8:30 and still no pizza. Called and they weren?t even apologetic.

darien-mckenzie
27.10.2022

To ensure timely dining, they need to provide food at least one and a half hours later than what they claim. However, tonight we waited over two hours for a cheese pizza!

braxton-mckenzie
27.10.2022

I had a terrible experience at this Casey's location. It took two hours to get our pizza, and when it finally arrived, it was the wrong order. I called four times during that wait, and each time they assured me it was on the way. An hour and a half later, we finally received the correct pizza, but it wasn't very good. I've ordered from several Casey's before, but I will never order from this one again.

nathanael19-horse282
27.10.2022

Very clean, nice staff, I was fast, out and out.

streich-lolita
27.10.2022

I got an offer fron my rewards and when i tried to order online paying cash or using my car i was told it was not accepted for this purchase. Whe. I called she said she could take my order at the end i asked if i could use my rewards and she said no. This is ridiculous....

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR code for the menu of Casey's

Suggested nearby restaurants.