J. Dominick's Trattoria - Poughkeepsie

We had dinner at J. Domenick’s last evening with family from CT. Previously we have always had a delicious meal and great service here. We were very dissalojnted with our food last evening. My crabmeat stuffed filet of sole tasted very fishy along with the so called crab meat stuffing hardly containing any crabmeat, mainly bread crumbs. I barely got through a quarter of the meal and wouldn’t eat anymore and spoke to the waitress about this. Another family member had the stuffed crab meat shrimp dish and again the shrimp was like rubber with no crab meat in the stuffing. A third family member had veal parmigiana dinner and said the tomato sauce was very watery, not good for the money that we were paying Unfortunately the quality of the food was not up to our expectations at all, which disappointed us as long time customers of J. Domenick’s. We were also surprised that a Manager didn’t even come out to apologize for the issue of our food.

If you get a reservation on a night with live music request not to be put in front of the singer. They will just walk away if you complain and tell you to leave. Extremely rude hostess and we will never go back. We have eaten there many a time and the food is decent but not worth the attitude from the front of house staff.

Very good food. Plenty for the next day We will be there again

Terrible service here, from the food, to the rude owner. To the horrible wait times to even get an appetizer. 2 hours to get our dinner for 3. What a shame. Also, the prices are high for the low quality of food. Chicken felt like rubber. Don’t recommend coming to this horrible place.

They close at 10. We came in at 8:52 and they wouldn 't seat us. They said they were closed because the kitchen closes at 9. Ridiculous!!! It wasn 't 9!In response to your reply: Ridiculous reply. You changed your hours to close at 9, after your hostess said We close at 10 . Doesn 't matter, it wasn 't 9!! I 've worked at many restaurants. If someone comes in 5 minutes before closing, they get served! Not even an apology. Very poor customer service!