Goodfellas Pizzeria - Poughkeepsie

The pizza is consistently amazing and never soggy. It has a wonderfully crisp crust. Excellent!

We enjoyed a good pizza here, but it would have been even better with fresh mushrooms.

I moved to the area two years ago and tried out several pizzerias to discover my favorites. I keep finding myself returning to Goodfellas repeatedly. They offer a wide variety of options for a pizza place, with great pizza quality and size, and the diner dishes are exceptional. If you have allergies, just communicate clearly, and they will do their utmost to assist you. The dining area is separate from the pizza counter, which is a nice touch. They do charge around $1 for credit card transactions, but that's to be expected. In short, it's by far the best pizzeria in the Spackenkill area.

Let’s talk about Goodfellas. This restaurant has been a regular spot for my family for the past eight years. I’ve been bringing my kids here since they were little, and now they feel like part of the family. But beyond the wonderful experiences and welcoming atmosphere, the food is fantastic. I’ve never had a bad pizza or a meal that wasn’t delicious. This place is truly exceptional, which is why it has been around for so long. You won’t be disappointed—head over for a great meal!

I often come here for lunch. I usually get the buffalo chicken pizza, while my fiancé orders the chicken marsala pizza — both are incredible! They even let us showcase our $2 inspection stickers!