Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Janelle K likes about Pusateris Chicago Pizza:
First time trying Chicago Tavern Style Pizza! Really lovely restaurant that makes you feel at home right away with both indoor and outside seating. I can't say enough about the lovely ladies working there as the customer service was so warm, welcoming and attentive. Really a special place to check out if you're in the area. Will say the sauce is on the sweeter side so be forewarned if that's not your thing but everyt... View all feedback.
What Lou S doesn't like about Pusateris Chicago Pizza:
Just awful food and service. Served a raw in the center pizza after waiting a very long time for it with not a lot of people in the place. Rude staff never checked on us after serving the order. Ate a few bites, paid, left almost a whole pizza on the table. Staff could care less. Too busy gossiping among themselves very loudly. Never again. View all feedback.
First time trying Chicago Tavern Style Pizza! Really lovely restaurant that makes you feel at home right away with both indoor and outside seating. I can't say enough about the lovely ladies working there as the customer service was so warm, welcoming and attentive. Really a special place to check out if you're in the area. Will say the sauce is on the sweeter side so be forewarned if that's not your thing but everything was fresh and clearly made with love.
I'm sad that I probably won't be back through Stuart, FL anytime soon. I'll be dreaming about the Chicago Fire pizza until then. It's the best pizza I've had in 11 years, to the day! (Golden Boy in San Fran) It was all just luck. Travel home after a week in the Keys, looking for somewhere to spend the night. The Mrs finds the Old Colorado Inn and they have a vacancy, so we detour to Stuart. A week of seafood and we were looking for anything besides seafood. This pizza joint pops up and I initially read about the roast beef sandwich and I'm sold. We make the short walk over. Scanning the menu I see the Chicago Fire pizza and it's something I couldn't pass up. The waitress (super nice) sold my wife on the Alfredo pizza, add spinach, which my wife also loved. I rearranged the cooler to take the leftovers of the Chicago Fire pizza home, 7 hrs away. We just heated it and I reluctantly shared the pizza with my wife. She loved it too. You folks in Stuart are lucky. Good pizza is rare.
Cute little pizza place in Stewart. I went with my south chicago friend and she claims it is closest to chicago pizza she's had. Plenty of sausage and cheese!!!Service was very good and fast. Next time we go I gotta try the chicago hot dog that looked pretty good!!!
Some may say this is just another pizza place. NOT. Pusateri's exemplifies Chicago thin pizza better than anywhere I've been outside of Chicago. AND, they do it perfect every time. Been back twice this visit already. Hope to make it back a third time.
This place has amazing Chicago style pizza. Literally one of my favorite pizza places in Florida!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
