Colonel Mustard's Pub Grill

Colonel Mustards is our favorite spot in Port Perry! The salmon is exceptional, and I always order it when I visit. The patio is fantastic, and the service is consistently top-notch. I want to give a special mention to Kayla, who has served us during our last few visits and provided outstanding service. Overall, it's a wonderful place!

I ordered a chicken burger, and it was terrible. Everything tasted like it came straight from the freezer, and nothing was fresh. The cheese on the burger seemed to have just been microwaved. I took one bite, had a few fries, and ended up leaving the whole plate untouched. The restaurant is in desperate need of renovations; it felt dark and had an unpleasant smell inside. To top it off, the glass they gave me for my sparkling water was dirty. I definitely won’t be returning.

Apart from the inconsiderate, noisy diners in the enclosed sunroom, we had a really enjoyable dinner after relocating inside. Our server, Tara, was outstanding! She definitely knows the menu thoroughly, and we appreciated her service. The mussels in red wine sauce were probably the best my husband has had in quite some time, and the portion size was generous. My wings and fries were delicious as well. The menu offered good value and a variety of choices. We'll definitely return, but we’ll be more selective about our seating next time!

Fare price food, the environment was too loud for me so I will try to sit outside next time. Their tiger shrimp was amazing! And food portions are awesome. Friendly service and delicious food.

The food was awesome. Kudos to the chef. The bruschetta stole the show and was to die for. The bartender put a good margarita together and overall the service was good but man that bathroom was horrible. It was like being Indiana Jones trying to dodge traps and by traps I mean pee. It's a bar so that goes with the territory but wow, that was a lot of pee.