Reviews
What massiel Negron doesn't like about Rum Bay:
Very disappointed with the food. It was terrible! Used the water taxi which cost $6.00 per person. Server has great, very friendly and informative. We ordered Mahi tacos. The tortilla was cold, dry and hard. Two Snappers were not fresh and fried in old oil reused. Both were dark inside and not flaky. Baked potato was over cooked and dry. Terrible, terrible. Don't let the pictures fool you, it's all about the taste an... View all feedback. What Jim Schowalter likes about Rum Bay:
We visited this restaurant to celebrate our anniversary and had a fantastic time. Our server, Melissa, was exceptional. We asked for drink recommendations, and they were spot on for our tastes. I ordered a delicious blackened mahi mahi sandwich, which I thoroughly enjoyed. Overall, we had a great experience! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
This place is a hidden gem! Take a short ferry ride out to the island, and after a very short walk, you?ll reach the restaurant. We took our family there for a...
read moreSo fun!! Great seafood!! The lobster was decadent! Highly recommend the tacos and the bartender is attentive and makes a great cocktail ?
Very disappointed with the food. It was terrible! Used the water taxi which cost $6.00 per person. Server has great, very friendly and informative. We ordered M...
read moreVacation Dinner our last evening in FL (10/10/21 We took a 60 sec. car ferry across the water to get to the restaurant (NOTE! We came in from the wrong directio...
read moreGreat place to stop for a bite or just get a cold drink on a hot day. They don't have a lot of boat slips which is kinda disappointing since you can only get th...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more