Reviews - Pitman Bakery
Reviews summary
**Restaurant Review: A Bakery in Pitman That Divides Opinions**
Nestled in the heart of Pitman, this bakery elicits a mix of reactions from patrons. While some have been frustrated by the owner's contentious behavior toward the local community, others praise the establishment for its delicious cakes and accommodating staff. Customers commend the bakery's reasonable prices and fresh ingredients, with standout offerings like custom carrot and cannoli cakes delighting taste buds. Despite some hiccups in cake designs, the willingness to rectify issues leaves a positive impression. Ultimately, this bakery seems to be a hidden gem striving for community warmth amidst contrasting experiences.
Was Karyn T at Pitman Bakery a mag?
Very good and reasonably priced cake. The owner made a custom carrot cake for my birthday and was accommodating to my husbands picky requests. It wasn’t a stereotypical carrot cake, didn’t have all the extra add ins, but that turned out to be a good thing. We compared it directly to a Whole Foods carrot cake, and everyone liked Broadway better, primarily because it was less sweet. Very good cream cheese frosting as w... View all feedback.
What Shelley Eckardt dislikes about Pitman Bakery:
They're a regular bakery. I ordered a baby yoda cake for my son's 8th birthday. 1. I ordered orange and blue as piping (decorations) and it was an ALL white cake with orange and blue printing! 2. The baby yoda was horrible. The person is not an artist by any means. 3. The buttercream icing was the ordinary sugary type of icing you can get at shoprite for much cheaper. $45 for a 1/4 sheet cake, I expected professional... View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 24.07.2023
If I could give zero stars, I would. The primary reason is the terrible and unpleasant demeanor of the owner. It’s disheartening to witness how she treats her neighbors and local businesses; it’s simply appalling. The lack of support and total disrespect she displays on a daily basis is concerning. I've personally seen her burst into other businesses, yelling and screaming, calling the police, and lodging complaints. Her behavior has caused disruptions and made several patrons feel uncomfortable on multiple occasions. I can’t support someone with such distasteful behavior, especially coming from a grown woman. I hope she eventually learns to cooperate with those around her and becomes a better neighbor, particularly in a vibrant town like Pitman, which is striving to foster a welcoming environment centered on community. Alternatively, I would welcome a new owner with a better attitude and a positive business approach, especially since I’ve heard this establishment is up for sale.
I ordered a vanilla sheet cake with peanut butter icing for my grandma's birthday, and it was enormous! The price was fantastic, and it tasted amazing! The entire family loved it.
Very good and reasonably priced cake. The owner made a custom carrot cake for my birthday and was accommodating to my husbands picky requests. It wasn’t a stereotypical carrot cake, didn’t have all the extra add ins, but that turned out to be a good thing. We compared it directly to a Whole Foods carrot cake, and everyone liked Broadway better, primarily because it was less sweet. Very good cream cheese frosting as well. When they said the 9” cake was $25, my husband paused and said, “are you sure?” He’s paid twice that for similar sized cakes in other local bakeries. Thank you!
They have the best donuts around! Definitely the best cream filled powder donuts in this area!!!
We ordered a cannoli cake from them and it was the best one we ever had. Beautiful and moist. Next best thing to homemade cake. Totally recommend and we will be using them more in the future.
