Fratello's - Pinehurst

Italian, Pizza, Salads
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19102159800

Menu

A complete menu of Fratello's from Pinehurst featuring all 14 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Nestled in Southern Pines, this charming Italian restaurant elevates the dining experience with its authentic cuisine and welcoming ambiance. Guests rave about the delicious New York-style pizzas, house-made dishes inspired by family recipes, and outstanding service from the owner, Sal, who adds a personal touch. The warm atmosphere, complete with clean white tablecloths and the occasional karaoke night, makes patrons feel at home. Though a few experienced minor service hiccups, the overall consensus is one of quality food and a memorable dining experience, making it a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Bettie

Images

Fratello's Food Fratello's Food Fratello's Food Fratello's Food Fratello's Outside Fratello's Food Fratello's Food Fratello's Inside

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 822 reviews

Was Carol B at Fratello's a mag?
I was craving authentic Italian food and found this charming little restaurant near my motel. I really appreciated the quaint and peaceful atmosphere. The clean white tablecloths added to the overall appeal. I... View all feedback.

What Kristen M dislikes about Fratello's:
Wow, I used to think Olive Garden was subpar, but this place really makes them seem like fine dining. After waiting over an hour for my DoorDash order to arrive, what I received was absolutely terrible. View all feedback.

carol-b-fish894
Carol 15.02.2024 - 04:44

I was craving authentic Italian food and found this charming little restaurant near my motel. I really appreciated the quaint and peaceful atmosphere. The clean white tablecloths added to the overall appeal. I...

kristen-m-cactus8208
Kristen 15.02.2024 - 04:44

Wow, I used to think Olive Garden was subpar, but this place really makes them seem like fine dining. After waiting over an hour for my DoorDash order to arrive, what I received was absolutely terrible.

hugh-v
Hugh 15.02.2024 - 04:44

The pizza and atmosphere are really good. I also enjoy the lasagna. The owner, Sal, is quite the character.

oschinner-3
Bettie 03.05.2023 - 08:26

The food was delicious with generous portions. The staff were attentive, friendly, and professional. I would certainly dine here again.

lupe-christiansen
Lupe 03.05.2023 - 08:26

After 14 years of searching for authentic New York-style pizza, we finally found it! We ordered a large white pizza, and it was outstanding. The restaurant has a fantastic atmosphere that brings back memories of the places I used to visit in Brooklyn and Queens. The owner, Sal, personally delivered our pizza, making the experience even more special. I can't wait to return!

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.