Virgil's At Cimmiyotti's - Pendleton

Steak, Seafood, Meat

Virgil's At Cimmiyotti's

Virgil's At Cimmiyotti's
4.1 / 5 (1542 reviews)

Description

Cimmiyotti's offers a mixed dining experience, drawing both praise and criticism from patrons. While many appreciate the perfectly cooked steaks, delicious food, and an extensive drink menu, others express disappointment in cramped seating and inconsistent service. Guests enjoy standout dishes like crème brulee and ribeye but criticize the lack of attention from waitstaff and unseasoned vegetables. Ambiance varies, with some finding the downstairs cozy compared to the hot, crowded upstairs. While some recommend avoiding busy times to enhance the experience, loyal customers return for the inviting atmosphere and quality meals, suggesting Cimmiyotti's has the potential to delight.

Last update: 19.06.2026 from: Annalee

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 1542 reviews
annalee-waggoner-1
05.10.2024

During my first visit, I ordered the halibut, and it was delicious! I would definitely order it again. The food was fantastic, and the service was excellent.

christina-powell-eng-1
05.10.2024

Wow! It was like stepping back in time. The ambiance was wonderful, the service was top-notch, and our food was delicious.

chris-adams-chef657
06.09.2024

This place is a little gem in our small town. The service is fantastic. The only reason it's not a 5 star is because my lobster wasn't perfect. The steak was amazing, however.

tony-magee-bank7
05.10.2024

The atmosphere is the best I've experienced in years, and both the service and food were exceptional!

bob-palladino
06.09.2024

I ordered prime rib and a baked potato, but the baked potato was so overcooked that it wouldn’t even melt the butter, making it nearly inedible. The prime rib was decent, but nothing special. We also tried the beef stroganoff, which had absolutely no flavor—it tasted like nothing more than water and flour over pasta. I might give it one more chance, but if the experience is just as disappointing, we won’t be returning.

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the place at no extra cost.

You can also pay for your meals with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.