Madison's - Pendleton
Madison's
Menu
The menu of Madison's from Pendleton comprises about 111 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $11.5 for a dish / drink.
At Madison's, we pride ourselves on our unpretentious dining philosophy, offering dishes made to order with high quality, hand-picked ingredients. Our traditional dishes come with an occasional twist, and we make all our desserts in-house. We prioritize using ingredients without high fructose corn syrup, offering Mexican Coke, Mexican Sprite, and San Pellegrino with cane sugar. With one of the best stocked bars in Indiana, we specialize in whisk(e)y and offer flights. Our wine selection is vast and notable, and we also serve craft cocktails made with infused spirits, simple syrup, and hand-squeezed juices. Enjoy craft and import beers in a warm and welcoming atmosphere where we treat you like family.
Images
Feedback
Madison's restaurant offers a mixed experience that has left diners divided. While some rave about the creative dishes like baked brie and filet mignon, others have encountered significant delays, inattentive service, and a disappointing atmosphere. Complaints about food wait times and limited menu options, especially on special occasions, overshadow some of the culinary excellence. Additionally, inconsistencies in service quality and cleanliness have been noted, leading to uncertainty about the dining experience overall. Despite memorable meals and friendly staff, many patrons feel Madison's may be losing its touch as a fine dining establishment.
We dined early 4:45 and were delighted with the great service and delicious food. Our waitress was very attentive to our needs, food was served promptly. I highly recommend giving Madison’s a try.
Food was very good. Ambiance kinda blah. Service the absolute worst we have ever had. No drink refills, pushy and rushed to take order, had to walk to bar to get the check. Bartender took our payment. When we walked out the waitress was sitting at a table chatting with another waitress. Wow.
This has always been one of our favorite spots. However, we hadn't visited in about six months, and we've noticed that their new menu is quite different, featuring more sandwich options instead of entrées. Unfortunately, the service was very slow, and we ended up waiting a long time for our meals. The wait staff seemed inexperienced and didn’t provide the best service. Additionally, there were bugs buzzing around us throughout our meal. When we finished dinner, the hosts came over and asked if we had eaten yet. While they had updated some of the decor, we still found ourselves dining at a vinyl tablecloth, which didn’t quite give off the ambiance we were hoping for. Overall, it didn’t feel like the fine dining experience we expected, and I’m not sure we’ll come back.
The restaurant features simple yet inviting decor, and their char-grilled salmon entree is truly delicious and expertly prepared. There’s a limited selection of wines and beers, but plenty of beverage options to choose from. The menu offers a variety of reasonably priced dishes, ranging from casual fare to more refined cuisine. To top it all off, their desserts are delightful and pair perfectly with smooth coffee, all served with a pleasant touch.
Full Menu
Entrées
Fried Apple Bacon Cheddar Flambe$12.0
Deviled Egg (6)$5.0
1/2 Dozen Chicken Legs (6 Pieces)$15.0
Black Tie Tuna$14.0Specialty Pizzas
Artichoke Spinach Roasted Chicken Pizza$16.0Starters
Spicy Sausage And Tomato Penne$18.0
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 2.7 / 5 (2418 reviews)#17 Fast Food in Pendleton BurgersMcDonald's
W Interpark Dr 9000, 46064 Pendleton, US
"Nasty hicks, bunch of young kids sitting talking on their phones acting ghetto. Their manager Kit ain't no better and none of them had on uniforms. Th..."
★ 3.6 / 5 (136 reviews)#18 Fast Food in Pendleton BurgersMcDonald's
Enterprise Drive 11, 46064 Pendleton, US
"The drive thru line moved quickly and the staff were friendly"
★ 2.9 / 5 (2298 reviews)#10 Mexican in PendletonTaco Bell
7159 S State Rd 67, Pendleton, IN, 46064, 46056, United States
"Got what we ordered this time it was great."