Prime 16 - Pelham

American, Salad, Pub
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Prime 16

Prime 16
4.2 / 5 (2591 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Pelham offers 44 different menus and drinks on the menu for an average price of $8.3.

Prime 16, located in the charming Village of Pelham, NY, is an inviting American restaurant boasting an impressive overall rating of 4.1 stars. Join us today from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM and indulge in the dishes you've been craving. To ensure you don’t miss out, be sure to reserve your table by calling (914) 576-0700. For those who prefer dining at home, you can easily order from Prime 16 through Uber Eats or DoorDash. If you're intrigued by our menu but would like to explore more culinary options, consider checking out nearby favorites like Pelham Cafe and Macelleria Italian Steakhouse. Have you dined with us before? We’d love to hear your thoughts, so feel free to leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Nicolas

Images

Prime 16 Outside Prime 16 Logo Prime 16 Menu Prime 16 Food Prime 16 Logo

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 2591 reviews

This beloved local gem specializes in gourmet burgers and boasts an impressive selection of craft beers. Diners rave about the juicy, flavorful burgers, with options to customize or choose from thoughtfully crafted designs. The casual atmosphere makes it a great spot for a relaxed meal. However, service can be slow, with longer wait times for food, and some customers have reported issues with their orders. While the menu features vegetarian options, there are inconsistencies in food quality and presentation. Despite these drawbacks, it remains a cherished destination for burger enthusiasts.

miguel-87
16.07.2023

The restaurant offers a great selection of American craft beers on tap, all of which are delicious and not mainstream. The burgers are also very tasty. One downside is that there is no WiFi available.

dd-user-3
16.07.2023

The restaurant is small with small tables that are not very comfortable. The menu design is interesting with a leather flap, but the rest of the menu looks cheap with plastic binder inserts. The cauliflower bites appetizer was disappointing, with very small pieces of cauliflower that were overpriced. The burgers we ordered were not great quality, with the sriracha bacon burger being very greasy and the meat falling apart. The sweet potato fries were bland and seemed like they had been cut in half to make it look like more. The smoker burger was okay but not worth the price, with cold bun and overly salty kale. The portion sizes were also inconsistent, with only a few slices of pickles served on the side. The water also had a strange taste. Despite the disappointing food, the waiter was nice and kept refilling our water.

yuki-1
16.07.2023

This local burger restaurant is excellent. You have the option to create your own burger as well. It is a casual spot to enjoy a gourmet burger and more. They also offer a wide variety of local beers.

nicolas-ankunding
25.04.2025

The place is small, small tables. Not too comfy. Menu design looked kind of cool, leather flap. The coolness stopped there, the rest of the menu looked like cheap plastic binder inserts. Now to the food. We ordered the cauliflower bites as an appetizer.I 've had these in plenty of other places, the plate they bought out for us looked like a plate someone already ate from. Thepieces of cauliflower were the size of the tip of my pinky. These were extra mini cauliflower. This was sad and unbelievablefor $5.95!!!! Major ripoff!!! We ordered 2 burgers, the sriracha bacon with sweet potatoe fries and the smoker burger withkale/garlic. The sriracha burger was superr greasyyyy toook 1 bite and the grease was pooling in my plate below. The meat wassuper crumbly, it was falling apart. The amount of fries in the silver cup was unbelievable as well. It looked like they cut thefries in half to make it appear as more fries. Plus they had no flavor, except for freezer flavor. The smoker burger was ok butnot worth 16.95$. The bun on the bottom was cold. And the kale. I mean how can u mess up sauteed kale/garlic right? Well theymanaged to do that. It was supppeeeerrrrr salty!!!!!! Unbearably salty i could not finish it and it was only a tiny amount aswell. O and we also got pickles on the side. It was literally 3 individual slices of pickles- sliced into chip size. Well I got3 and my bf got 1.5 slices. I don 't know what was up with their portions here. Were they running out of food so decided to tryto make the food appear to be more? And I guess the just ran out of pickles all together. The water also tasted funny. At leastthe waiter was nice and kept giving us water for the salty kale.

reynold75
25.04.2025

A place near and dear to my own heart, I've been coming here since they first opened the Pelham location. The beer selection is phenomenal, with great classics and some you've never even heard of. The burgers are great, you can customize one from theground up or pick from the list of designed burgers. I personally always order the designed as there was clearly a lot ofthought that went into them and they are delicious. On top of all that, the atmosphere is very chill, the service is great andthere are even vegetarian options available at a burger joint. Great restaurant.

  • Salads

    5Th Avenue Salad
    5Th Avenue Salad
    $10.9
  • Burger

    8 Oz. All American Burger
    8 Oz. All American Burger
    $11.8
    8 Oz. The Smoker Burger
    8 Oz. The Smoker Burger
    $12.8
    8 Oz. Maui Burger
    8 Oz. Maui Burger
    $12.8
  • Entrées

    Spiced Candied Bacon
    Spiced Candied Bacon
    $4.9
  • Sandwiches

    Ahi Tuna Po Boy Sandwich
    Ahi Tuna Po Boy Sandwich
    $11.8

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.