Nonna's Pizza - Peekskill
Nonna's Pizza
Menu
A complete menu of Nonna's Pizza from Peekskill featuring all 21 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.
Nonna's has emerged as a mixed bag for diners, with some noting the charm of its diverse menu and courteous staff. While a few dishes, like the Chicken Francese and pizza, received praise for freshness and taste, others fell short, with complaints about soggy fries and unremarkable baked ziti. Service quality was inconsistent, with experiences ranging from rude interactions to helpful staff. The restaurant's pricing sparked debate, but many appreciated its reasonable options. Despite some setbacks, loyal patrons continue to enjoy takeout, hinting at a restaurant with potential amidst areas needing improvement. Overall, it’s a place worth a visit, albeit with tempered expectations.
Images
Feedback
Was Francesca Reynolds at Nonna's Pizza a mag?
As an O.T.R driver, I stopped at this restaurant two nights in a row for the first time. I ordered a large cheese pizza, a spinach roll with marinara sauce, and a tiramisu dessert. The bill came out to $29, and I added a 15% tip, making it a little more expensive. I was disappointed that they wanted to charge extra for Parmesan cheese, which I thought was unnecessary. However, the food was decent overall. View all feedback.
What Eldridge Ritchie dislikes about Nonna's Pizza:
I ordered food online and it never came. I called them up and they said the system is down and they can't refund me the money. The lady on the phone was extremely rude and I spent 30 dollars plus a 7 dollar tip. This is unacceptable and I wouldn't recommend anyone to go there. If you want pizza go elsewhere. This is also a chain business so if you wanted to support a small business owner this isn't a small business o... View all feedback.
Delicious food , great service . Went during the holiday season. Everything was excellent ?
French fries and chicken pliers were all soggy. stuffed shells had funky taste! in the rule they get their pizza, which was once great. service was very polite!
With the Pandemic lingering over our lives food always helps to comfort us no matter what the occasion is. I ordered the food the day before and the staff at Nonna’s were very helpful and accommodating despite the short notice and before New Year’s Eve. I picked up the food the next day and it was ready at the time they said it would be ready. The Chicken Frances’s was very good-lots of lemon and garlic yummy- as well as the Chicken Parmesan and Broccoli Rabe with sausage. I will recommend that you order or go eat at the restaurant-the food is great.
As an O.T.R driver, I stopped at this restaurant two nights in a row for the first time. I ordered a large cheese pizza, a spinach roll with marinara sauce, and a tiramisu dessert. The bill came out to $29, and I added a 15% tip, making it a little more expensive. I was disappointed that they wanted to charge extra for Parmesan cheese, which I thought was unnecessary. However, the food was decent overall.
We all have our own opinions about prices and what we're willing to pay. We dined at this restaurant and ordered lamb and chicken marsala for two, along with a hot cocoa and a glass of house wine, which came out to be $55. Your thoughts on the pricing may vary.
Menu
Vegetarian Dishes
Beverages
Sauces
Wine
Sides
Italian
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.2 / 5 (1909 reviews)Seafood Cheese Steak Burgers DrinksNY Firehouse Grille
Welcher Avenue 63, 10566 Peekskill, US
"I highly recommend the chicken marsala bites! Yum!"
★ 4.4 / 5 (799 reviews)Asiatic Mediterranean Italian AmericanApropos At The Abbey Inn
Fort Hill Rd 900, 10566-2286 Peekskill, US
"We had a wonderful meal and look forward to returning"
★ 4.1 / 5 (2489 reviews)Mexican Seafood Asiatic American WineDivision Street Grill
North Division Street 26, 10566 Peekskill, US
"The restaurant contacted us to cancel the reservation."