Reviews - Forno's

#18 - Pizza - Peekskill, #32 - Seafood - Peekskill, American

Reviews summary

This local eatery offers standout buffalo chicken pizza and a highly praised Sicilian slice, both noted for generous toppings and great crust. Friendly staff and reasonably priced dishes add to the appeal. Popular menu items include baked ziti, chicken parmesan wedges, and white clam sauce over linguine, delighting many diners. However, experiences can vary—some customers have expressed disappointment with reheated calzones and white pizza. Despite mixed feedback, the restaurant remains a favorite for those seeking hearty Italian-American fare, especially on casual days when comfort food is key. Overall, it’s worth a visit, with hits that largely outweigh the misses.

Overall Total Score
2.6 out of 5
Average | 1117 reviews

Reviews from various users

Sirved

Last update : 17.02.2025

4.4 ★ from 1099 reviews
rosemarie-rosa-1
17.02.2025

Great pizza, soup and salads. One of my faves in this part of town.

trev-h-bird5903
17.02.2025

The staff at this restaurant is consistently excellent, and their pizza is incredibly tasty!

jake-scott-restauran
17.02.2025

While traveling, I decided to sample a white pizza and curly fries. I'm sorry to say it was the most disappointing meal I've ever had from a pizza shop. I definitely wouldn't recommend it—zero out of ten!

courtney-commercial-1
17.02.2025

The menu is excellent, and the staff at the counter are very friendly. They offer a wonderful variety of pizzas.

Top-rated

Last update : 14.11.2023

jason-b-6
14.11.2023

I have never left this place feeling disappointed! I've tried pizza all over the country, and without a doubt, Forno's ranks among my top three favorite pizzerias!

smyrx-s
14.11.2023

Good food and good people. Definitely worth a try if you haven't.

j-m-95
14.11.2023

Best buffalo chicken slice in the area. A lot of large pieces of tender buffalo chicken and great crust and cheese. The Sicilian pizza is also awesome. Great prices too.

t-t-4
14.11.2023

I couldn't have enjoyed our meal more! We ordered some snacks and a large pizza to enjoy on a rainy day. I always make sure to try different pizzas when I'm in New York, and I will definitely be returning!

donald-m-8
14.11.2023

The chicken parm wedge was not so good the chicken was paper thin and the cheese was burnt. I will never order from there again. It's a shame there very close to my home ..

Menu

Last update : 15.03.2023

2.6 ★ from 8 reviews
barrows-marcellus
15.03.2023

Great pizza and desserts! Grandma style pizza is amazing! I would highly recommend this restaurant.

barrows-marcellus
15.03.2023

The employees were extremely friendly. The food was delicious. We got baked ziti, chicken parm wedge and white clam sauce over linguine. Definitely visiting again.

hcrist-firefighter9
15.03.2023

I used to like this place but was so upset on th calzone. I was hoping to have a nice piping hot calzone with sasusage and mushrooms instead got one from the shelf reheated and sausage slapped on the bottom of the calzone..not inside..add insult to injury...after 35 min and i only live a few blocks away.. sahme on you guys!

clovis-davis
15.03.2023

Really poor. I ordered once and food was amazing. But last three times were terrible. Ordered an expensive square and got all bread and very little sauce, Cheese and toppings. Really disappointed and won't give them another shot. Better places around.

maryjane-armstrong
15.03.2023

During my visit, I opted for a white pizza and curly fries. I can honestly say that this was the worst meal I’ve ever had from a pizza shop. I’d rate it a perfect 10 out of 10 for being completely unworthy of recommendation.

FAQ

The community at Menu has uploaded these Pictures of Forno's from Peekskill. They depict the meal space at Forno's, including the interior, location and of course, striking Photos of fine dishes from Forno's.

Good Rated Restaurants near Peekskill