Casey's - Paragould

#23 - Pizza - Paragould, #32 - Seafood - Paragould, Donuts
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
3.7 / 5 (959 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Casey's from Paragould contains about 501 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $3.2 for a dish / drink.

**Exploring Casey's: A Mixed Bag of Experiences** Casey's offers a visually appealing and well-maintained store, popular for its friendly atmosphere and extensive selection of snacks and drinks. While the pizza and deli items, including customizable salads, receive positive acclaim, some customers have reported issues with service, including being ignored and rude staff interactions. Additionally, gas prices at this location tend to be higher compared to competitors, which has driven some patrons to seek alternatives. Nevertheless, patrons appreciate the cleanliness and organized layout, as well as the beneficial rewards program, making Casey’s a noteworthy stop for convenience store enthusiasts.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Hilton

Images

Casey's Outside

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 959 reviews

Was Edythe Erdman at Casey's a mag?
The place is clean, friendly, and always stocked with snacks, drinks, and comfortable storage items. The fuel pumps are numerous, so you rarely have to wait when you're just stopping by for a quick grab-and-go. The pizza and deli section also offers a fantastic salad that you can customize with your favorite ingredients. Definitely stop by and see for yourself! View all feedback.

What Bettye Emmerich dislikes about Casey's:
Was ignored at the counter trying to order a sandwich watched as the girl made a pizza start to finish finally ask what I needed after telling her three times I wanted a chicken salad sub she told me they were out of chicken salad thanks for wasting my time won't be back View all feedback.

zachariah-mohr
29.04.2023

The gas prices at this location tend to be higher than at other places in the city. However, the station and pumps are clean and well-maintained. The staff is friendly, and the food is excellent, particularly the pizza. It's a charming little branch with a wide variety of dishes and drinks available. The employees are polite and respectful, and the bathrooms are kept clean.

edythe86
29.04.2023

The place is clean, friendly, and always stocked with snacks, drinks, and comfortable storage items. The fuel pumps are numerous, so you rarely have to wait when you're just stopping by for a quick grab-and-go. The pizza and deli section also offers a fantastic salad that you can customize with your favorite ingredients. Definitely stop by and see for yourself!

qweber-bank54
29.04.2023

The restaurant is incredibly clean, and the staff is very friendly. They are always ready to help with anything I need.

hoppe-hilton
29.04.2023

I absolutely LIEBE Casey 's. Your hospitality is over and over any other convenience store I've ever seen. Their donuts are always fresh as well as their sandwiches and wraps. If you get the reward card from Casey, you will be SAVE SO MUCH MONEY

llowe-1
29.04.2023

More expensive for gas or propane. Nice looking store very kept up with but I will the drive 1 mile to Murphys because they are cheaper. They do have rewards programs which is nice.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.