Bartolo's Pizza - PALMYRA
Bartolo's Pizza
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Bartolo's Pizza in PALMYRA. At the moment, there are 16 menus and drinks on the menu.
**Discovering Bartolo's: A Culinary Gem in Hershey-Palmyra** Bartolo's has long been a beloved destination for pizza, subs, and Italian specialties in the Hershey-Palmyra area, celebrated for its homemade bread and unique sweet sauce. Loyal patrons rave about the exceptional quality and generous portions, often making the drive from neighboring towns for the outstanding cold turkey sub and other offerings. The family-run establishment combines a cozy atmosphere with consistent, friendly service, and supports local youth sports teams, solidifying its place in the community. Despite recent critiques regarding ingredient changes, Bartolo's remains a cornerstone for fans seeking authentic Italian flavors.
Images
Feedback
Was Ludwig Brakus at Bartolo's Pizza a mag?
Just okay. The pizza sauce was a bit sweet for my taste and the amount of topping was a bit light. We did like the thick crust version. Not the best I have had but pretty good. View all feedback.
What Dave W dislikes about Bartolo's Pizza:
This place used to be great, but apparently they have fallen to the crunch of money in the last few months, and are becoming second rate. We used to go here at least 2 to 3 times a month and their pizza and Bartolos special sub, which used to be awesome, have gone downhill a LOT. It'a almost like they're using different ingredients and MUCH less meat than they used to. I will no longer be using them as there are far... View all feedback.
Great Cheesesteak. The pizza at Bartolo's Pizza is just OK, I prefer my pizza with a thinner crust. The pizza here has a thicker crust and is a little light on the cheese. I will say however, that the cheesesteak here is above average. The rolls appear to made on site and the meat and cheese is plentiful.
Good pizza. What more do I need to say. The pizza here is good and not over priced so it works for me!!
I live in Palmyra and with six pizza shops they have the best pizza hands down. My only complaint is that they pay the delivery, at times I am lazy to go after my meal.
Delicious New York-style pizza! The sauce and cheese are of high quality. The dough is thin and chewy, yet remains light and airy thanks to its freshness.
Not the best pizza ever but ok.
Menu
Salads
Italian Specialties
Pizza
Soft Drinks
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-Code for the menu
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.4 / 5 (638 reviews)#11 Pizza in PALMYRA SandwichesRoma Pizza
South Railroad Street 19, 17078 PALMYRA, US
"Delicious, authentic cuisine! Highly recommended."
★ 3.1 / 5 (1462 reviews)#10 Fast Food in PALMYRA BurgersWendy's
E Main St 743, 17078-1911 PALMYRA, US
"10:12 am...doors locked, no one's around"
★ 4.0 / 5 (7252 reviews)American Vegetarian Gluten Free CasualFunck's
West Main Street 664, 17078 PALMYRA, US
"Had the fish tacos and they were amazing. Maybe the best I had."