Local Pizza - Osprey

#37 - Seafood - Osprey, Pizza, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Local Pizza

Local Pizza
3.6 / 5 (1303 reviews)

Menu

On this webpage, you will find the complete menu of Local Pizza from Osprey. Currently, there are 91 dishes and drinks available.

Local Pizza has garnered mixed reviews, with some patrons praising its delicious food and friendly service, particularly highlighting the pizza and impressive wings. Many appreciate the homey atmosphere and skilled cooking in a wood-fired oven. However, issues have arisen regarding food quality and safety; several customers reported wilted ingredients, undercooked meals, and unaddressed complaints. A recent inspection revealed multiple food items held at unsafe temperatures, prompting a warning from health officials. While loyal customers cherish the restaurant’s offerings and value, inconsistencies in service and meal preparation have led others to reconsider their dining choices. Overall, Local Pizza remains a polarizing dining option.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Eric

Images

Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Food Local Pizza Menu

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 1303 reviews

Was Tony Chatfield at Local Pizza a mag?
My wife enjoys this restaurant. It's a quirky local spot. I tried the cheese pizza slices, which were delicious. The crust was particularly outstanding. My wife, on the other hand, always goes for the meatball sub, and she loves it every time. Despite the distance from our home, we plan on returning because we enjoy supporting local establishments. Our waitress provided excellent service, although I did not catch her... View all feedback.

What Anthony Davidson dislikes about Local Pizza:
Definitely don't recommend , me and 2 of my employees walked in this establishmeny sat down for almost 20 minutes and still wasn't waited on. While the manager sat and played with TV channels rather than ask us what we want to drink good customer service. And we were the only people there besides one other couple. Service: 1 View all feedback.

dennis-raftery
04.01.2024

During our inspection, we found several food items being held at unsafe temperatures: pizza sauce at 51F, cooked chicken at 53F, meatballs at 54F, fresh mozzarella at 51F, ricotta sauce at 49F, pomodori sauce at 52F, and cooked chicken at 65F. The operator informed us that these items had been held for less than three hours and promptly moved them to a cooler. Additionally, we noted that there was no time marking on foods being held using time as a public health control, such as the pizza. The operator stated that the pizza had been held since 12:00. A warning was issued, and corrective action was taken to address these issues.

nicole-grannan
04.01.2024

"This restaurant is excellent, with delicious food and friendly, efficient service. I have tried several pizzas, appetizers, and wings and have always been impressed. We will definitely be returning regularly, especially considering the surprisingly reasonable prices. Thank you for bringing more flavor to the Osprey/South Sarasota area!"

kelly-nicole-school7
04.01.2024

The food at this restaurant is superb! Even the gluten and dairy free pizza was amazing. Our server, Eliana, was a delight. The restaurant has a very mom and pop feel, which I love. It is very clean and the staff is attentive even when they are busy. I highly recommend this place, especially for those with dietary restrictions looking for delicious options like the dairy free and gluten free pizza that was cooked to perfection.

eric-adams-forest115
13.03.2025

I had lunch with my family on a Saturday afternoon. There were five of us and we all enjoyed our food. I had the Pretty Fly for a White Pie pizzzetta and really enjoyed it. It was a good size for a lunch portion and the crust was about as good as it gets for Florida pizza. The service was great too. I 'll definitely be back. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch

dan-guiher-3
13.03.2025

This place is a *gem*! Properly hand made (genuine) Italian style pizzas, with the usual other-Italian fare on the menu. Crust is thin, stone baked, and the toppings are high end. Great to eat in or for a take away. Friendly staff, excellent communications and timings just right. Very highly recommended! Service: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner

  • Red Pizzas

    Pretty Fly For White Pies
    Pretty Fly For White Pies
    Meat Me At The Corner
    Meat Me At The Corner
    Right In The Kisser
    Right In The Kisser
  • Gluten Free & Cauliflower Crust

    Meatball & Pesto
    Meatball & Pesto
  • Specialty Pizzas

    Meatballs Fresh Garlic & Parmesan
    Meatballs Fresh Garlic & Parmesan
    Sausage & Green Onion
    Sausage & Green Onion

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.