Lucy's Pizzeria - Orem

Pizza, Sandwiches, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +18018027777

Menu

The menu of Lucy's Pizzeria from Orem includes 76 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $6.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Orem, UT, is a beloved Italian restaurant, renowned for its delicious offerings and impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Diners rave about the inviting atmosphere and diverse menu, which caters to all tastes, including vegetarian options. Whether you're enjoying a casual meal for two or hosting a lively gathering with friends, be sure to call ahead at (801) 802-7777 to secure your table. If you're feeling adventurous and want to explore other culinary delights, consider visiting Wallabys Smokehouse or Cafe Zupas. We invite you to share your dining experience by leaving a review!.

Last update: 11.12.2025

Images

Lucy's Pizzeria food Lucy's Pizzeria food Lucy's Pizzeria food Lucy's Pizzeria food

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 658 reviews

Was User at Lucy's Pizzeria a mag?
As a lifelong New Yorker, I have a discerning taste when it comes to pizza, particularly when it claims to be New York style. Many places attempt to capture that essence, but Lucy's truly nails it! The dough, sauce, cheese, and generous slice sizes are all spot on for authentic New York pizza. We also love coming here for lunch. The value is excellent; the amount you pay for the portion size far exceeds what you’d ge... View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Lucy's Pizzeria:
Service was slow. You have to cut your own pizza, grab your own utensils, grab your own plate, and clean up after yourself and others. They ask for a tip to make your pizza that's it, no customer service. With four people working, not much service wasgoing on. The place was dirty, I didn't see anyone cleaning or clearing tables. Pizza was okay definitely not Real New Yorkstyle pizza, had way better. View all feedback.

deschamps-caroline
Caroline 03.02.2023 - 10:01

They lost my business. expect them to pay $70 for a cold meal. it is a dull in, but expect to operate the whole experience. from sitting, grab her to clean herself. usually this kind of thing is not a big thing and can be done well. Lucy?s not, and I doubt they'll find out. the service here used to be good. with appetizer and a free dish olive and pickle out before the meal. Your pizza is served when it's hot and ready. you need to set up for your food, wait an hour to pick up cutlery, serviettes, teller yourself.? and when your pizza is finished, they will tell them a summer so they can pick it up on the window. it was hardly warm and through my second piece it was cold. the cheese sticks we had ordered came after we finished with the pizza, and the free olives and pickles are now 3 dollars and are not filled again. for a 70 dollar meal not worth it! so expensive for a bad experience.

jordy-hermans
Jordy 03.02.2023 - 10:01

Finally found a place that taste like pizza from back home (NJ). The cheese and crust are so good, I just wish the pizza was a little firmer instead of flimsy towards the front. This place is definitely ?NY Style? APPROVED. The wings were pretty good too. I?ll be back.

white-cameron
Cameron 03.02.2023 - 10:01

This pizza was delicious! Thin crust that was tasty and excellent sauce. They offer a lunch special, however ; we ordered a whole pie for leftovers. Our server suggested we try the Firesticks, those are awesome if you like a little spice in your life! They also had really good Ranch for a dipping sauce. Our server was great, the pizza was wood fired and excellent. I suggest you check it out for yourself!

rangel-daniel
Daniel 03.02.2023 - 10:01

Great little pizzeria. During the dinner rush, the wait to get our food was a bit longer than we would have liked. However, service was incredibly kind, pizza was classically tasty, and restaurant was clean. Great prices too, especially if you have the local starving student card coupons.

cummings-hermina
Hermina 03.02.2023 - 10:01

Friendly staff, clean restaurant. Ordered 2 slices, got a whole pie which was nice of them to do. Pizza is of true NY fashion (big, thin, cheesy, slice). As Dave Portnoy would say good undercarriage , good crisp, good flavor. I 'd give it a 7.9, which is pretty good for not being on the east coast. Overall great experience, great pizza!?

  • Dessert

    New York Cheese Cake
    New York Cheese Cake

    A slice served with your choice of fruit, dark chocolate, carmel, or enjoy just plain.

    $4.5
  • Salads

    House Salad
    House Salad

    Chopped romaine, cheese, olives, pepperoni, tomatoes, and pepperoncini.

    $4.0
  • Calzone

    Calzone
    Calzone

    Choose your flavor: Snickers, Milky Way, Reese's, 3 Musketeers, Twix, Oreo, or Nutella and we combine it with cheesecake to make an oozing pocket of joy!

    $5.5
  • Starters & Salads

    Antipasto
    Antipasto

    Chopped romaine, topped with cheese, tomatoes, olives, and a variety of peppers and meat.

    $6.6
  • Steaks

    Black Angus
    Black Angus

    Did someone say steak? a 6oz angus steak with sautéed mushrooms, onions mozzarella.

    $8.6
  • Chicken Wings

    Wings
    Wings

    (10) Tasty chicken wings doused with your choice between our signture bullafo, sweet chili, or bbq sauce. Served wtih dressing of your choice.

    $10.1

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.