Reviews - Strobelli's

Mongolian, Chinese, American

Reviews summary

Strobelli's presents a varied dining experience, with loyal patrons praising its fresh, handmade dough and generous toppings. While some diners rave about the rich flavors and satisfying portions, a few express disappointment over inconsistent quality, including cold and incorrectly topped pizzas. Many appreciate the inviting atmosphere and the personal touch that comes from a locally-owned establishment. Despite some inconsistencies in delivery and pricing, the overall consensus favors its delicious taste and hearty servings, making Strobelli's a notable choice for pizza lovers willing to support a community-focused business.

Overall Total Score
3.7 out of 5
Very good | 217 reviews

Was Camron Effertz at Strobelli's a mag?

We chose this restaurant for our first outing after COVID-19 closures, and it remains my favorite! I was concerned that the experience wouldn't be as enjoyable, but I was pleasantly surprised. View all feedback.

What Sandy B dislikes about Strobelli's:

I've been a regular at this restaurant for some time and have even recommended it to family and friends, all of whom have enjoyed it. However, I went there yesterday to pick up my pizza, and when I got home, it was cold, tasted like it had been made the day before, and the crust was hard. This was not what I expected from you. I'm not sure if I can return after this experience. I might have to look for another pizza... View all feedback.

Reviews from various users

Yelp

Last update : 06.05.2024

4.1 ★ from 214 reviews
emily-b-dog9479
06.05.2024

Such good pizza! Perfect for a family event and the people are super nice. I usually get takeout but I'm sure dining in is great

katie-p-student55
06.05.2024

My friends and I visit every pizza place in Sacramento in search of who has the best pizza around. We decided to visit Strobelli's which turned out to be a fairly pleasant experience. We always make sure to give an honest review despite what reviews of places are on Yelp. We checked Strobelli's yelp page and found in many pictures, there was a man with a cowboy hat in them. We joked around about how maybe we'll see him when we go in and to my excitement, the cowboy hat guy was at the bar with some guests. That isn't really part of the review but that was definitely a highlight for me personally. I'm pretty sure he's the owner but I'm not entirely sure. Something I've come to realize is bars have fairly good pizza. It's usually a decent price, but it's great flavor and quality. Strobelli's is no different. We always order a standard large pepperoni to keep everything uniform with the other pizza places. The size of the pizza was a relatively good size. They were definitely generous with the pepperonis which is always appreciated. They are also generous with the amount of cheese and sauce you get. The sauce had a great flavor, and the pizza had some grease on it, but had the right amount on it. Overall, the taste was great. We don't have any negatives about the pizza itself. However, price is a little rough. It was 28$ not including tip. When we go to these pizza places we have a rating out of 10. A 5/10 means it is average and anything below is worse, anything above is better. When it comes to taste, Strobelli's was one we rated 10/10. We had nothing negative to say about the pizza. We rated the Price a 7/10. It's a little higher than a lot of pizza places, but for the actual quality you're getting, it's somewhat reasonable. After factoring in a lot of different qualities we looked for, we give Strobelli's an overall 8.75/10. It's a very nice small family business which exceptional flavoring. If you can justify the price you're spending, then it is 100% a must try. We look forward to our return.

sandy-b-teacher74
06.05.2024

I've been a regular at this restaurant for some time and have even recommended it to family and friends, all of whom have enjoyed it. However, I went there yesterday to pick up my pizza, and when I got home, it was cold, tasted like it had been made the day before, and the crust was hard. This was not what I expected from you. I'm not sure if I can return after this experience. I might have to look for another pizza place. Unfortunately, I can only give them one star.

april-k-rabbit868
06.05.2024

The pizza was delicious, though a bit expensive. The service was great as well. Next time, we'll opt for dining in and check out some of their beer offers.

rachelle-p-church7
06.05.2024

I think of dieting, then I eat pizza. ~Lara Stone On Tuesday evening we placed an order by phone for an XL Combination Pizza for my boyfriend, daughter and I. When it arrived the gentleman scanned my card, handed me the receipt and the biggest pizza box you ever did see. When they say big, they mean BIG, this 24 pie was loaded with cheese, fresh veggies, mouthwatering canadian bacon, salami, pepperoni and big thick cubes of flavorful sausage! I had a foodgasm, it 's that cheesy, greasy pizza you want! Not to mention it 's thin crust so you can do like the New Yorkers do and fold your pizza in half. My favorite way to eat a pizza, since it keeps your toppings in! I would highly recommend patronizing this small business that began in 2009! Every morning they make their dough by scratch and all of their toppings are fresh! It 's been a minute, before yelping days, but they are one of my favorite pizza places, my mom and I loved their calzones and epic portions for the quality and price! Great for work and birthday parties! We 'll be back when dine-in is open! Support small and local, especially now when they need our business the most! Happy National Beer and Pizza Day!

Menu

Last update : 14.08.2020

3.3 ★ from 3 reviews
toy-ray
14.08.2020

This restaurant is fantastic! It's enjoyable trying to see how much of all your favorite items you can fit into the bowl they give you - it's a massive pile.

camron48
14.08.2020

We chose this restaurant for our first outing after COVID-19 closures, and it remains my favorite! I was concerned that the experience wouldn't be as enjoyable, but I was pleasantly surprised.

vschmeler
14.08.2020

I have never felt so unwanted in an empty restaurant.

FAQ

These Images from Strobelli's from Orangevale have been contributed by the Menu community. They showcase the eatery at Strobelli's, its interior, location and of course, fantastic Shots of the delicious dishes from Strobelli's.

Good Rated Restaurants near Orangevale